LOADING ...

Extreme Heat Is Another Legacy of Segregation

Yessenia Funes Jan 14, 2020. 13 comments

Racism has consequences, especially in an era of climate change.

A new study, published Monday in the journal Climate, has found that most communities with a history of redlining—the government-led practice of discriminating against communities of color by denying them home loans and insurance and labeling their neighborhoods “hazardous” to real estate investors with literal red lines on maps—experience higher land surface temperature than nearby communities that weren’t redlined.

This is alarming. The heat is only getting started , and it will only worsen if we continue to put more greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. That raises the risk of heat-related illness and even death . The harsher urban heat island in traditionally redlined communities could only increase the stress on communities of color as the climate crisis unfolds.

The researchers, many of whom are based at the Science Museum of Virginia, took a look at the urban heat island effect within specific neighborhoods in communities after realizing there was a 9-degrees Celsius (16-degree Fahrenheit) difference between the hottest and coolest parts of Richmond, Virginia, during a 2017 heat wave. Turns out the locations with the hotter temperatures weren’t random, either.

“Many of these hottest spots corresponded to the neighborhoods that were redlined in the 1930s,” co-author Jeremy Hoffman, the chief scientist at the museum, wrote in an email to Earther. “The next summer, we saw the same pattern emerge in our mapping of Baltimore’s urban heat. The more we looked into it, the more clear the pattern became.”

The study found that 94 percent of the 108 urban areas studied experience temperatures as much as 7 degrees Celsius (12.6 degrees Fahrenheit) higher in formerly redlined neighborhoods than non-redlined. And the authors don’t think this is a coincidence. They believe that the historical housing practices in the U.S. are directly related to this issue.

The study doesn’t identify a causal link, but it suggests the discrepancy in heat is likely related to a number of things. For one, heat-absorbing infrastructure such as highways and giant housing projects can make a community way hotter. Then there’s the absence of green space, which can keep neighborhoods cool and reduce air pollution.

Researchers have found a similar phenomenon in California cities where redlined neighborhoods had a higher number of cases of asthma hospitalization. This new finding around the legacy of redlining highlights the importance of examining history when analyzing present-day policy.

“Understanding how we got here can help us be honest about the present situation and be hopeful about how we can move forward from here,” Hoffman said. “Our study suggests that decisions that were made almost 100 years ago are playing out today as a climate and health inequity. That makes me hopeful that by making good, inclusive, equitable decisions today, we might positively change the lives of people right now and for the next 100 years.”

Low-income communities and communities of color already face disproportionate risk during extreme heat. Heatstroke, dehydration, exhaustion, and heart and asthma attacks could happen to anyone exposed to extreme levels of heat. But vulnerable individuals are less likely to have access to or be able to afford air conditioning, for example, to cool off when this type of warmth strikes. As the new study shows, they have to cope with the reality that their neighborhoods actually get hotter, too.

It paints a pretty clear picture of the impacts policy decisions can have almost a century later. These findings still need more research so we can better understand the causes and ideally address them as the world gets even hotter. Communities of color are constantly facing multiple threats—and none of it is by accident .

13 Comments

Other Yessenia Funes's posts

'We're Fighting for Our Rights': The EPA's First Bill of Rights Decries Trump's Deregulatory Tactics 'We're Fighting for Our Rights': The EPA's First Bill of Rights Decries Trump's Deregulatory Tactics

For employees who’ve spent decades working for the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Trump administration is like nothing they’ve ever seen before. That’s exactly why—for the first time ever—the agency’s union employees have authored a Bill of Rights to set the agency back on track to meet its mission.The American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) began organizing EPA staff...

Doomsday Is Now Just 100 Seconds Away Doomsday Is Now Just 100 Seconds Away

We are 100 seconds to midnight, which means doomsday has never been closer. Deadass.On Thursday, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists moved the clock 20 seconds closer to midnight aka the end of civilization. The last move forward was 2018 when the world reached two minutes to midnight amid threats of climate change, nuclear fallout, and cyberwar. This time...

It's So Cold in Florida, Iguanas Are Falling From the Sky It's So Cold in Florida, Iguanas Are Falling From the Sky

It’s cold in Florida, so you know what that means: falling iguanas. No, seriously. The National Weather Service Miami office issued a warning Tuesday that temperatures could dip into the 30s and 40s on Wednesday, leading to iguanas plummeting out of trees. And Twitter users confirmed Wednesday morning that many iguanas did, in fact, do just that.Meteorologists and local...

The World Was Supposed to Eliminate This Greenhouse Gas—But Emissions Hit a New High Instead The World Was Supposed to Eliminate This Greenhouse Gas—But Emissions Hit a New High Instead

The world’s quest to reduce an extremely potent greenhouse gas isn’t going as well as we thought it was, according to a new study. HFC-23, known as fluoroform, is a greenhouse gas that has 12,000 times the global warming potential of carbon dioxide does. Findings, published in Nature Communications on Tuesday, show that emissions from India and China have...

Suggested posts

Joe Biden Says No Scientists Back Bernie Sanders’ Climate Plan. He's Wrong Joe Biden Says No Scientists Back Bernie Sanders’ Climate Plan. He's Wrong

The Iowa caucuses are just over a week away, and Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden are neck and neck in the polls. In the past few days, the two have sparred over corruption and Social Security and gun control, and earlier this week, both campaigns released videos coming after the other candidate.But things escalated further on Friday when Biden...

A Massive Locust Swarm Poses an 'Unprecedented Threat' to East Africa A Massive Locust Swarm Poses an 'Unprecedented Threat' to East Africa

A grim report from the United Nations warns that unusually large swarms of locusts will be descending upon East Africa in the coming months, in what could be the worst infestation in a quarter century. The pests could pose a serious risk to crops and livelihoods in the region.“The current swarms represent an unprecedented threat to food security and...

'We're Fighting for Our Rights': The EPA's First Bill of Rights Decries Trump's Deregulatory Tactics 'We're Fighting for Our Rights': The EPA's First Bill of Rights Decries Trump's Deregulatory Tactics

For employees who’ve spent decades working for the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Trump administration is like nothing they’ve ever seen before. That’s exactly why—for the first time ever—the agency’s union employees have authored a Bill of Rights to set the agency back on track to meet its mission.The American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) began organizing EPA staff...

Earth's Carbon Dioxide Level Is Set to Make One of Its Biggest Annual Leaps Ever Recorded Earth's Carbon Dioxide Level Is Set to Make One of Its Biggest Annual Leaps Ever Recorded

Carbon dioxide. We should stop emitting it.Scientists say it . The United Nations says it . Greta Thunberg says it . Even big finance corporations say it (even if they’re actively impeding doing it).And yet here we are on the brink of a year that will see one of the biggest jumps in atmospheric carbon dioxide on record. The...

The Trump Administration Just Gutted Clean Water Protections The Trump Administration Just Gutted Clean Water Protections

The Trump administration’s Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Army Corps of Engineers just removed federal protections for hundreds of thousands of small waterways and many of the nation’s wetlands. Later today, EPA administrator Andrew Wheeler will announce the change at a conference of the National Association of Home Builders, an industry group that pushed for loosening clean water rules.This...

Maybe These Davos Guys Have Some Good Ideas About Climate Change (They Do Not) Maybe These Davos Guys Have Some Good Ideas About Climate Change (They Do Not)

  Davos season is a beautiful time of year when rich, powerful people gather in a Swiss mountain town to talk about Big Ideas. Ensconced in this familiar backslapping environment, they also occasionally tell us how they really feel about some of the most pressing issues facing humanity like rising inequality and the climate crisis.I look at these things and...

Doomsday Is Now Just 100 Seconds Away Doomsday Is Now Just 100 Seconds Away

We are 100 seconds to midnight, which means doomsday has never been closer. Deadass.On Thursday, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists moved the clock 20 seconds closer to midnight aka the end of civilization. The last move forward was 2018 when the world reached two minutes to midnight amid threats of climate change, nuclear fallout, and cyberwar. This time...

Carbon Dioxide Reached a New High in Humanity's Existence Carbon Dioxide Reached a New High in Humanity's Existence

We’re not even through the first month of 2020, and we already broke the record for the day with the most carbon dioxide in all of human history.Carbon dioxide in Earth’s atmosphere hit 415.79 parts per million (ppm) at Mauna Loa Observatory on Tuesday. It’s not surprising carbon dioxide levels hit a new daily high, but the new atmospheric...

Coke's Reason For Not Ditching Single-Use Plastic Is Bullshit Coke's Reason For Not Ditching Single-Use Plastic Is Bullshit

Public concern about the climate and plastic crises is surging, and more and more brands are developing more sustainable business practices to cash in on said concern. But not Coca-Cola, which is doubling down and blaming consumers for its choice.At the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Coke’s sustainability chief said that it will keep selling its products in...

A Spanish Beach Town Is Filling Up With Sea Foam A Spanish Beach Town Is Filling Up With Sea Foam

Tossa de Mar is an absurdly beautiful vacation town in Catalonia, Spain. It’s got clear blue water views, a variety of European cuisines, and for a limited time only, massive amounts of weird ass sea foam.A powerful storm blasted the region on Tuesday, turning the ocean into a tempest. That whipped up a thick blanket of sea foam that...

Language