LOADING ...

In The Shadow Of The Moon is a sci-fi misfire from the director of Stake Land

Katie Rife Sep 25, 2019. 6 comments

Time travel is a conundrum, for theoretical physicists and screenwriters alike. It’s cheaper to convincingly portray than, say, space travel, which makes it an appealing prospect for independent filmmakers looking to stretch their sci-fi dollar as far as possible. But it’s also an incredibly complicated and inherently contradictory concept—so much so that a logically seamless time travel story is, historically speaking, rather rare. In The Shadow Of The Moon, the latest from Stake Land and We Are What We Are director Jim Mickle, unfortunately proves to be the clumsy rule rather than its clever exception.

In The Shadow Of The Moon comes from Netflix, which has stepped in to fund the kind of mid-budget genre films that major studios have all but stopped making. This particular example is a hybrid, blending a gritty crime drama à la Mickle’s own Cold In July with a high-concept sci-fi story about a time-traveling assassin named Rya (Cleopatra Coleman) who’s working her way backwards from the year 2024 to 1988, when she has a fateful encounter with Philadelphia beat cop Locke (Boyd Holbrook). Lock nurses a True Detective-esque, decades-long obsession with this mysterious young woman, who reappears every nine years to kill a handful of people with a gadget that looks like the hilt of a lightsaber and is explained away with some gobbledygook about isotopes and remote detonation. The film is structured around these returns, which have something to do with the moon and which mark the exciting evolution of Holbrook’s facial hair, if not his performance.

The script by Gregory Weidman and Geoffrey Tock not only breaks a core screenwriting rule by telling rather than showing, but it also makes a point to tell in the most convoluted way possible. Laden with hackneyed banter and pseudoscientific jargon but distressingly short on internal logic, this is the kind of movie where a character will say, “If you’ve got a badge on your chest and a gun on your hip, I need you to move right now!” when “calling all units” would do. Add in heavy-handed voice-over at the end of the film that does everything but draw the audience a diagram of what happened over the preceding 110 minutes, and it’s all just too overwritten to take seriously.

This same combination of overindulgence and sloppiness extends to Mickle’s usually-much-tighter direction, which overemphasizes certain details—if you ever forget where (or when) you are, don’t worry, there will be a coffee mug or newspaper or local commercial to remind you within a minute or two—while completely neglecting others. Despite the aggressive Philadelphia-ness of it all, co-star Michael C. Hall randomly has a Southern accent; even worse, that accent comes and goes throughout the film. Most baffling of all is the scene where Locke’s pregnant wife dies, as pregnant wives must in these films, or else we wouldn’t know why the hero is so sad. One moment, she’s fine—or as fine as someone can be while they’re in labor. The next, her head flops to one side, her eyes close, and just like that, she’s gone.

At least the gore is good. Rya’s isotope gizmo has some pretty gnarly effects, causing victims’ brains to liquefy in their skulls and come oozing out of their eyes, ears, and nose along with spurting jets of blood. (Why the poison that actually kills the victims has to be remote activated from the future remains unexplained.) Then again, the opening CGI shot of a skyscraper decimated by a terrorist attack looks like it was rendered 10 years ago, so even the effects are a mixed bag. In The Shadow Of The Moon is a disappointing misfire all around, but no matter—like so many other Netflix original films, it’ll be reabsorbed into the streaming void soon enough.

6 Comments

Other Katie Rife's posts

Varda By Agnès is a joyful, generous parting gift from the mother of the French New Wave Varda By Agnès is a joyful, generous parting gift from the mother of the French New Wave

Agnès Varda was never in any danger of becoming irrelevant. Where some artists creatively calcify with age, the visionary French filmmaker continued to nurture her curiosity about the world up until her death in March at the age of 90. That same curiosity drives what will stand as Varda’s last work as a writer-director, Varda By Agnès. Released as...

Celebrate Rock 'N' Roll High School's 40th anniversary with Shout! Factory and The A.V. Club Celebrate Rock 'N' Roll High School's 40th anniversary with Shout! Factory and The A.V. Club

2019 marks the 40th anniversary of Rock ‘N’ Roll High School, a film that’s survived such tragedies as the fall of its production company, New World Studios; the deaths of three of the four Ramones featured in the movie; and an attempted remake by Howard Stern, who announced his plans in 2008 and never followed through. Producer Roger Corman is...

Jawas are still a pain in the ass as The Mandalorian prepares for takeoff Jawas are still a pain in the ass as The Mandalorian prepares for takeoff

TV Reviews All of our TV reviews in one convenient place.Prev NextView All A friend of mine joked on Twitter that The Mandalorian should be called “Lone Wolf and Yoda” after the big reveal at the end of episode one, and, in this episode at least, she was right. “The Child” opens with The Mandalorian (Pedro Pascal) walking through...

Most of Stephen Merchant’s survival skills involve being tall Most of Stephen Merchant’s survival skills involve being tall

In 11 Questions, The A.V. Club asks interesting people 11 interesting questions—and then asks them to suggest one for our next interviewee.Stephen Merchant is impossible to ignore, and not just because he’s 6'7". The co-writer and co-director of the British incarnation of The Office, Merchant’s introduction to Hollywood was winning a Golden Globe for the series in 2004—an experience he...

Suggested posts

Stranger Things' David Harbour thought the show would be a "disaster" Stranger Things' David Harbour thought the show would be a "disaster"

David Harbour has clearly emerged as the MVP of the Stranger Things cast when it comes to doing press. Whether he’s posing for someone’s high school senior photos or officiating a wedding in his police chief’s costume , he has become a master of the art of making himself very endearing online—or at the very least, demonstrating that he’s...

Vanessa Hudgens and Josh Whitehouse on the value of "Christmas cheese" Vanessa Hudgens and Josh Whitehouse on the value of "Christmas cheese"

It’s not even Thanksgiving, but we’re firmly in the throes of heartwarming Christmas movie season. With The Knight Before Christmas , Netflix makes its latest entry into the marketplace. The film, which stars Vanessa Hudgens and Josh Whitehouse, involves the improbable transport, via “old crone” of a heroic fourteenth century knight into modern day Ohio, where he meets a weirdly...

Netflix announces a Vikings sequel series, Valhalla Netflix announces a Vikings sequel series, Valhalla

Good news for anyone who didn’t consider “six seasons” to be a sufficient amount of time to spend watching people stare at each other ominously while brandishing axes: Variety reports that Netflix has begun development on a sequel series to History’s Norse-themed drama Vikings. Titled Vikings: Valhalla, the series will take place 100 or so years after the original...

Here's what's coming to (and going from) Netflix in December Here's what's coming to (and going from) Netflix in December

First things first: Austin Powers is back, baby, yeah! In a totally shagadelic turn of events, Netflix will begin streaming all three (3!) Austin Powers movies come December 1. This, of course, doesn’t bode well for the rest of the streamer’s December slate, which is packed with holiday films, stand-up specials, epic new series, and the streaming premiere of a...

A Christmas Prince: The Royal Baby trailer proves Netflix has truly gone cuckoo for Christmas A Christmas Prince: The Royal Baby trailer proves Netflix has truly gone cuckoo for Christmas

Two years ago, Netflix got the Hallmark suits sweating with A Christmas Prince , a meme-able trifle about a reporter’s tryst with the prince of an ever-idyllic country called Aldovia. The tradition rolled on with last year’s Royal Wedding , but Netflix is emphasizing kooky over cozy these days, meaning that if the Christmas Prince franchise wants to keep...

Dolly Parton and the cast of Heartstrings on the best Dolly songs to sing at karaoke Dolly Parton and the cast of Heartstrings on the best Dolly songs to sing at karaoke

“9 To 5"? “Jolene”? The decades-spanning discography of country music icon Dolly Parton is chock-full of songs that are ripe for a sing-along, but which is most likely to bring the house down at a karaoke? We took to the red carpet at the premiere of Dolly Parton’s Heartstrings at Dollywood in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee to ask the cast and...

Varda By Agnès is a joyful, generous parting gift from the mother of the French New Wave Varda By Agnès is a joyful, generous parting gift from the mother of the French New Wave

Agnès Varda was never in any danger of becoming irrelevant. Where some artists creatively calcify with age, the visionary French filmmaker continued to nurture her curiosity about the world up until her death in March at the age of 90. That same curiosity drives what will stand as Varda’s last work as a writer-director, Varda By Agnès. Released as...

Netflix delivers your next true crime fix with The Confession Killer trailer Netflix delivers your next true crime fix with The Confession Killer trailer

Tired: Is it okay to think Ted Bundy was hot? Wired: Did Henry Lee Lucas really murder all those people? Netflix has released a trailer for The Confession Killer, the platform’s next true crime docuseries, which re-examines the case of Henry Lee Lucas. Like Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, and our good pal Ed Kemper, Lucas was fond of chatting about...

Forget it, Jake… It's a Netflix prequel to Chinatown from David Fincher Forget it, Jake… It's a Netflix prequel to Chinatown from David Fincher

According to Deadline, Netflix has worked out a deal to get David Fincher and Robert Towne to team up on a pilot script for a prequel to Chinatown. The plan for the series, if it gets that far, is for it to focus on a young Jake Gittes (played by Jack Nicholson in the film) as he does various...

Mike Birbiglia on the harsh realities of being a parent Mike Birbiglia on the harsh realities of being a parent

In his one man show The New One, now at L.A.’s Ahmanson Theatre, Mike Birbiglia struggles to come to terms with being a parent. It’s not always pretty, with the comedian both struggling to find a place in his new, larger family and to relate to his wife and child in a way that’s both effective and compassionate. With the...

Language