LOADING ...

Just Try to Understand This NYT Editor's Racist, Incoherent Twitter Thread

Libby Watson Jul 31, 2019. 5 comments

You know that feeling when you wake up after a late night watching the dumbass Democratic debates , defined by the moderators’ absurd commitment to centrist ideology and repeating Republican attacks as if those are good-faith questions about public policy , and an editor from the New York Times has done a thread about how black people from cities aren’t really from the places they’re from? Yeah. That very good feeling.

Last night, spokesperson for Justice Democrats Waleed Shahid responded on Twitter to Claire McCaskill, a former Senator who lost her race in the Midwest, who said that “free stuff from the government does not play well in the Midwest.” Shahid pointed out that Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib are also from the Midwest—an important point, since referring blithely to “the Midwest” as a place defined by its more conservative rural residents is inaccurate and reinforces the notion that only conservative whites matter.

This morning, the Times’ deputy Washington editor Jonathan Weisman responded to Shahid in this deeply fucked up fashion.

Hoo boy! Another gem from the guy that brought you, “A black...Muslim....from Minneapolis....to lead the Democratic Party????

Weisman later deleted the tweets and said he didn’t “adequately” make his point.

No shit!!!

The most charitable interpretation of his argument here is that you cannot define a region by the cities where a lot of the people live. (A majority of people in Minnesota live in the Twin Cities.) You cannot say someone is from Texas if they’re from Austin, which is apparently some sort of non-American colony of a more liberal country, and you can’t say someone is from the Deep South if they’re from Atlanta. From ATLANTA.

The troubling thinking behind this is that people who live in cities aren’t really from the state they are geographically located in because they’re more liberal than the rest of the state. This goes hand-in-hand a line of argument often used by racists, like the President of the United States, that minorities in cities aren’t really from here—they’re some other, alien nation within ours, and can’t be included when referring to the region or state that they literally live in. The Midwest must refer to its conservative white residents; the Deep South must only refer to the guys who look like Bull Connor, not the guys who look like MLK. (Three of the four members of Congress he picked are minorities, and the one white guy represents a majority-Latinx district.)

It’s truly unbelievable to insist that a civil rights icon like John Lewis isn’t really from the Deep South because he represents Atlanta. Not only would it be ridiculous if he were born in Atlanta, but Lewis was born to sharecroppers in Alabama, for fuck’s sake.

The Deep South does not belong to rural white people; in fact, the Deep South was built on the backs of slaves. In 1860, 44 percent of Georgia was enslaved. The most important factor in the making of the Deep South is that those states were the most reliant on slavery. Asserting that the black Congressman who represents Atlanta is therefore not representative of the Deep South, because the Deep South can only refer to the non-city bits that are white, is simply racist.

Weisman followed up these thoughts:

An interesting attempt to shift the goalposts happens here: Weisman says it’s not fair to say that Atlanta is synonymous with Georgia, which I don’t think anyone ever said. It is not synonymous with Georgia in the way that Marietta, a majority white city, is not synonymous with Georgia either. This is how language works. I also don’t know why we’re supposed to care what this guy’s in-laws think, either, but his relatives in Plymouth (84 percent white) and Shoreview (87 percent white) who don’t like Omar are not more important than the people who do.

What Shahid was doing last night in responding to McCaskill was pointing out how simplistic and inaccurate it is to refer to regions like the Midwest as defined only by the more conservative residents—who just happen to be white—as if they’re the only ones whose opinions really count.

That’s not to say that “winning the Midwest” can only be done through cities—though in a lot of cases it probably could, if you drive turnout in major population centers high enough—but it’s important to note, because none of these people would ever imply that the white rural representatives don’t really represent the states they’re from. At best, you’re serving the conservative agenda by acting this way; at worst, as The Atlantic’s Adam Serwer pointed out, you’re imitating the racist rhetoric of Donald Trump that says people from cities aren’t really American. Cities like Atlanta. Which happen to be minority black.

All of this matters because Weisman is the deputy Washington editor for the paper of record. He has a significant role in shaping the Times’ political coverage. If his assumptions reflect the paper’s institutional bias, or indeed if his assumptions are worked into the Times’ reporting, that might mean the Times is just not that good at understanding politics or racism in the age of Trump. Imagine that .

5 Comments

Other Libby Watson's posts

G/Oodbye G/Oodbye

Have you ever shown up at a party full of people you think are really cool, eager to impress and befriend them, but you get there a little too late, and you discover when you arrived that none of them are having a good time because they just found out their best friend died? I haven’t, but that’s kind...

Did Sebastian Gorka Fart on His Radio Show? Did Sebastian Gorka Fart on His Radio Show?

Everyone except me has been there: After a big meal, you shift in your seat a little and receive an unexpected visit from Mr. Botty Gas whom, unbeknownst to you, was waiting patiently at the door. The door to your butt.Given that this is totally natural and not something to be embarrassed about, I feel there’s no problem in...

The Congresswoman Who Wrote the Medicare for All Bill Is Sick of Democrats' Lies The Congresswoman Who Wrote the Medicare for All Bill Is Sick of Democrats' Lies

If you are a Medicare for All supporter, the recent discourse on the topic might have given you such high blood pressure that you’ve had to turn to our nightmare healthcare industry to fix it. But maybe this will soothe you: Rep. Pramila Jayapal, the author of the House Medicare for All bill—which many advocates consider superior to the...

Great News for 2020: Voter Purges Are Still Going Strong Great News for 2020: Voter Purges Are Still Going Strong

For Democrats looking to win in 2020, the prospect of voter suppression is a huge, ominous cloud on the horizon. Republicans have a varied and powerful toolbox at their disposal when it comes to suppressing Democratic voters, and they’ve used these tools to great effect. One of those tools is purging the voter rolls, which Republicans argue is necessary...

Suggested posts

The President Is Mad Online The President Is Mad Online

I regret to inform you that it’s Wednesday morning and the president is tweeting madly.It’s not even 10 a.m. on the East Coast. And yet Donald Trump has used so many caps, more than enough for one day: Unfortunately, the worst person you know (the president) tucked a (mostly, until the end there) good point in his morning tweets:...

This Senior Interior Official Has Had Major Trump Brain for More Than Two Decades This Senior Interior Official Has Had Major Trump Brain for More Than Two Decades

William Perry Pendley, a senior interior official, has cast doubt on climate change and made xenophobic comments, according to a report from CNN published on Tuesday.Pendley, who has been acting director of the Department of Interior’s Bureau of Land Management since July, has been a right-wing lunatic well before that was widely understood to be a lucrative career path....

Bernie Sanders Following Last Week's Heart Attack: 'I Am Extremely Motivated in This Fight' Bernie Sanders Following Last Week's Heart Attack: 'I Am Extremely Motivated in This Fight'

Presidential candidate and Sen. Bernie Sanders that he would change his campaign strategy to prioritize his health. Last week, Sanders suffered a heart attack in Las Vegas, NV. On Saturday, he returned home to Burlington, VT.“We were doing, you know, in some cases five or six meetings a day, three or four rallies and town meetings and meeting with...

Racist Team Cursed Racist Team Cursed

The Washington Redskins, a professional football team named after an actual racial slur, fired their coach, because they are 0-5 this year. Well, of course they are. If there is any sort of god in this universe, this team is cursed. You better fuckin believe it. The year is 2019. The name of this team is the “Washington Redskins.”...

Trump Spends His Day at a Golf Club Attacking Mitt Romney Trump Spends His Day at a Golf Club Attacking Mitt Romney

It must be something to be the president of the United States and have taxpayers bankrolling you while you hang out at your own golf club and tweet about someone you hate. But that’s Donald Trump!Facing increasing evidence of corruption that would’ve landed any other president in jail by now, Trump is still hanging onto the presidency, as belligerently...

Mouse in the (White) House Mouse in the (White) House

THEY FOUND THE RAT—or mouse, at least. (No, not that one .)As many, many White House reporters tweeted on Tuesday, a mouse fell from the ceiling and into NBC News correspondent Peter Alexander’s lap. Here’s some video of the poor little guy, desperately trying to escape death by wonk: Still, some brave reporters in the room appeared completely nonplussed:...

Just Another Day in Fucknutsville Just Another Day in Fucknutsville

Earlier today, Politico published a story under the headline “Just Another Day in Fucknutsville.”The story, by founding editor John F. Harris, is a long treatise about days gone by, in which a presidential impeachment inquiry would have landed with more weight. Because Trump is such a shitshow and because the modern 24-hour, digital media cycle facilitates shitshows, Harris writes...

People Are Cancelling the New York Times Again for Reporting on the Whistleblower's Identity People Are Cancelling the New York Times Again for Reporting on the Whistleblower's Identity

Yesterday, amid a long day of day of congressional testimony and presidential lunacy , the New York Times published a story about the identity of the whistleblower who first exposed President Donald Trump’s extremely suspect conversations with the Ukrainian president. While the paper didn’t reveal the person’s name, it reported that the whistleblower works with the CIA and was...

Washington's Biggest Idiots Offer $50K Reward to Expose Whistleblower's Identity Washington's Biggest Idiots Offer $50K Reward to Expose Whistleblower's Identity

When it comes to the ignominious title of “biggest idiots in Washington DC” there’s plenty of heavy competition , but only one undisputed heavyweight champion team: alleged criminal Jacob Wohl and conspiracy loon Jack Burkman, the Laurel and Hardy of conservative grifters whose repeated efforts to discredit any number of public figures have all inevitably ended in hilarious  disarray...

Talking To Individual Voters Is a Waste of Time Talking To Individual Voters Is a Waste of Time

You don’t have to spend money to go to journalism school. I will tell you how to write a story about a political campaign that is up to the standards of the national press. Your story won’t be worth a damn. Few of them are! You go to the campaign rally, or the speech, or the debate, or the...

Language