LOADING ...

Haas F1 Sponsor Rich Energy Denied Appeal After Losing Logo Case

Alanis King Jun 29, 2019. 19 comments

Rich Energy, the enigmatic sponsor of the Haas Formula One team, got taken to court over its logo recently and lost. The energy-drink maker said afterward that it was looking forward to returning to court so the “truth” could “emerge,” but Rich Energy was just denied its request for an appeal.

The official denial of Rich Energy’s request to appeal the copyright judgement from May, reported first by FormulaSpy, was sent to Jalopnik on Friday by Whyte Bikes, the company that took Rich Energy to court. That’s in addition to multiple other rulings, including one that said Rich Energy must either deliver all of the products with the infringing logo to Whyte Bikes, destroy them, or change them to no longer be infringing.

The entire legal battle is over the stag-head images in the companies’ logos, which Whyte Bikes found to be strikingly similar to each other. Rich Energy

has said its logo was “designed independently” of Whyte Bikes’ logo.

As a result of the original judgement, Whyte Bikes told Jalopnik it would seek an injunction for “the removal of the infringing copy of [its] logo from all Rich Energy’s branding, including but not limited to the Haas F1 cars.” Rich Energy soon

removed the logo from the cars anyway, saying it wanted to avoid “any media circus for the team” amidst the “baseless case” against it.

But the companies made a scheduled return to court Thursday, in which Rich Energy’s appeal request was denied and more detailed orders were given. Here’s the list shared with Jalopnik by Whyte Bikes, highlights ours:

Rich Energy can still push an appeal through, as shown in the orders above, but has to apply for permission by July 18—the date for when it’s been ordered to stop using the logo.

Whyte Bikes has yet to comment on the orders to Jalopnik, but we’ll update this story if the company does. Jalopnik has also asked Rich Energy for comment on the decision and its plans, and will update this story if we hear back.

Rich Energy continues to be an enigma in F1, from its

mysterious roots , to its strange tweets , to the financial documents showing that this F1 partner had 581 pounds in the bank in 2017. (Rich Energy CEO William Storey told Jalopnik those documents told an “irrelevant” part of the story, and more details are here.)

It’s all very odd, though, and the copyright case added to that—especially its

scathing judgement , in which a judge found Rich Energy CEO William Storey’s evidence to be “incorrect or misleading,” and that he was “involved in the manufacture of documents during the course of litigation to provide additional support for the Defendants’ case.”

The Haas team has generally stepped back in talking to media about the drama,

declining to comment on the copyright judgement and telling Jalopnik that its “due diligence of potential partners is a confidential matter” when asked about its vetting of Rich Energy as a partner.

But there are a few things that stick out in the list of court orders, aside from the kill date of July 18 for its logo. Rich Energy will have do something about its cans and products with the logo by August, for one, and according to the orders, the company will have to disclose can sales to Whyte Bikes. That’s interesting, considering the back and forth from Rich Energy itself on sales.

The judge in the copyright case from May, for example, asked Storey about a press quote from February that said Rich Energy had produced 90 million cans. When asked about that number, the judgement said Storey responded with a statement about strangely empty cans:

Mr Storey explained that it had produced 90 million cans, but had not yet filled and sold them. He said he would have to check the figures, but in 2018 he thought the First Defendant had filled and sold “circa 3 million cans” of Rich Energy drink.

In an interview earlier this year, Storey told instead Jalopnik Rich Energy had sold “over 100 million cans” and that the number was “growing rapidly by the day.” In that same interview, Storey said Rich Energy has “considerably in excess of eight figures in [its] bank account at any one time.”

Of course, even with the order that Rich Energy will have to disclose its sales of cans with the logos on them to Whyte Bikes, that information may never make it into the public forum. We’ll just have to see how it plays out, like most of the rest of the questions surrounding the company.

Update: Friday, June 28, 2019 at 5:18 p.m. ET: Storey responded to Jalopnik’s request for comment via email, writing that the latest hearing “involved the same judge,” and that Rich Energy is “pleased with developments in court and [is] looking forward to the denouement of process which is some way away.”

Update: Monday, July 1, 2019 at 1:59 p.m. ET: Whyte Bikes sent Jalopnik the official court order, which is mostly the same as above but in court speak. The interesting parts of it—including details about what we already knew, in light yellow, and new information, in dark yellow—are highlighted below.

The dark highlights are on a stipulation that says Rich Energy must provide Whyte Bikes with information involving its Haas F1 investments and payments, via the document, emphasis ours:

d. Figures showing:

i. Any sums of money invested in or made available to the First Defendant [Rich Energy], including for the avoidance of doubt sums invested in or made available to [Rich Energy] in connection with its sponsorship of the Haas F1 Team;

ii. Any sums of money invested by third parties in any other company or entity controlled by the Second Defendant [Storey] in connection with and/or pursuant to [Rich Energy]’s sponsorship of the Haas F1 Team;

iii. Full details of any sums of money paid or payable to the Haas F1 Team pursuant to the [Rich Energy]’s sponsorship of the Haas F1 Team, indicating in each case whether such sums were paid or payable by the [Rich Energy] or by any other entity;

Jalopnik has asked Whyte Bikes for details on these orders, such as whether the information will be made public depending on whether the case is taken to the Court of Appeal and the outcome there. We’ve also reached out to Rich Energy for comment on the more detailed orders, and will update this story if we hear back. (Rich Energy quickly responded, offering no further comment than what is in the update above.) 

Until then, the full court order is below.

19 Comments

Other Alanis King's posts

What The Characters Of Yu-Gi-Oh Would Drive In The Year 2020 What The Characters Of Yu-Gi-Oh Would Drive In The Year 2020

No matter how much our parents might have yelled at us to go outside instead, the things we watched on television as kids can play a big role in our ...

It's Never Really Goodbye It's Never Really Goodbye

When former Jalopnik Editor-in-Chief Patrick George reached out in 2015 about potentially writing for some car website with a funny name on weekends d...

Oh Shit These Bitches Are Pink Oh Shit These Bitches Are Pink

The yellow splitter guards Dodge Charger and Challenger owners drive around with were never meant to be fashionable, as Dodge intended them as shipp...

NASCAR Is Officially Testing A Sequential Shifter In Place Of Its Four-Speed Manual NASCAR Is Officially Testing A Sequential Shifter In Place Of Its Four-Speed Manual

NASCAR is testing a new car design scheduled to debut in its top-tier Cup Series in 2021, which would replace the sixth-generation race car that’s be...

Suggested posts

The Hungarian Grand Prix Is The Next Domino To Fall In F1's Doomed Calendar The Hungarian Grand Prix Is The Next Domino To Fall In F1's Doomed Calendar

Formula One wants to get back to racing sooner rather than later, and for some teams it might be a matter of survival that it does . Following the ca...

You Can Own Part Of F1's Ugliest Moment You Can Own Part Of F1's Ugliest Moment

For reasons perhaps beyond anyone’s understanding, F1 started running proboscis noses in 2014 . They were universally loathed, and quickly banned, an...

The Cost Of The F1 Shutdown Has At Least Two Teams Sweating Bullets The Cost Of The F1 Shutdown Has At Least Two Teams Sweating Bullets

The 2020 Formula One season has already been blown wide open by the coronavirus pandemic. A full 9 grands prix have been cancelled or postponed at th...

Sir Stirling Moss, Formula One and Mille Miglia Legend, Has Passed Away at 90 Sir Stirling Moss, Formula One and Mille Miglia Legend, Has Passed Away at 90

Formula One great Sir Stirling Moss, 90, has passed away this morning, according to an FIA press release. Though Moss never took home a championship,...

Formula One Won't Give Up On The 2020 Season Until October Formula One Won't Give Up On The 2020 Season Until October

The 2020 Formula One season schedule originally had a massive 22 race weekends on the board, but nine of those have already been cancelled or postpon...

Formula One's 2020 Season Continues To Dissolve Formula One's 2020 Season Continues To Dissolve

Following the absolute omnishambles that was the delayed-too-late Australian Grand Prix (above), Formula One has been postponed or cancelled an addi...

89-Year-Old Bernie Ecclestone Still Fucks, Fourth Child Due This Summer 89-Year-Old Bernie Ecclestone Still Fucks, Fourth Child Due This Summer

Former Formula One boss and billionaire ghoul of note Bernie Ecclestone has confirmed that his 44-year-old wife of 8 years Fabiana Flosi is with chil...

McLaren Formula One Drivers Take Voluntary Pay Cut As The Team Weathers Coronavirus Shutdown McLaren Formula One Drivers Take Voluntary Pay Cut As The Team Weathers Coronavirus Shutdown

McLaren Formula One racers Carlos Sainz and Lando Norris have both agreed to take a voluntary pay cut as many team members have been furloughed. The ...

Formula One Teams Won't Be Ready For 2021 Rules Until 2023 Formula One Teams Won't Be Ready For 2021 Rules Until 2023

Nearly two weeks ago the FIA approved a delay in the new Formula One regulations slated for 2021, pushing the change out to the 2022 season. As team...

Formula One Drivers, Soccer Men, And Streamers Are Turning To Virtual Racing Formula One Drivers, Soccer Men, And Streamers Are Turning To Virtual Racing

It’s 2020, and because we can’t have fun anymore, F1 is either postponed or cancelled , and many of us have gaps in our weekend plans. However, the w...

Language