LOADING ...

The Biggest Flaw in Eddie Alcazar's Perfect Is Its Lack of Substance

Charles Pulliam-Moore May 14, 2019. 5 comments

Eddie Alcazar’s Perfect is like that rare, fleeting Instagram video ad whose arresting visuals actually manage to make you stop scrolling for a moment to drink it in and consider tapping through. Even if it’s confounding at face value, there’s the promise of something more illuminating should you look past its glamorous veneer. But, like so many other high concept sci-fi films that came before it it, Perfect ultimately suffers from letting its focus on style outweigh the energy put into its substance, leading to a film that’s as disappointing to mull over as it is utterly delightful to look at.

We’re introduced to the world of Perfect through the eyes of Vessel 13 (Garrett Wareing), the film’s unnamed protagonist, who’s being given a second chance at life just after he’s murdered someone. The film is sparse in terms of dialogue (from screenwriter Ted Kupper) and worldbuilding, but what little we learn about Vessel 13 is difficult to interpret save for a few important things. At some point before the film’s present day, Vessel 13 killed a woman he was physically intimate with, and while he’s horrified to realize what he’s done once he’s come out of his fugue state, there’s something inside of him, some part of him, that enjoyed his actions. And that part must be cut out of him, both literally and figuratively speaking.

Rather than directly addressing the brutality of Vessel 13’s crime, Perfect instead emphasizes the sterilized, constructed perfection of the movie’s world and how here, people have developed ways of eradicating anything within themselves that threatens to disrupt the harmony of things. In a flashback, we’re introduced to 13’s mother (Abbie Cornish) who explains that she’s sending her son to a special place where people will make sure he never has an “incident” like the previous one ever again, but what’s most ominous and telling about the moment is how purposefully devoid of emotions it is. When 13 asks his mother whether his murdering someone makes him a “bad” person, she assures him he isn’t, but there’s a distinct lack of any sort of warmth or empathy in both the mother’s response and the sterile setting where the conversation takes place which gives you the sense that everyone’s working with different ideas of good and evil than we are.

Perfect follows Vessel 13 as he travels to a luxe, futuristic rehabilitation center center where he undergoes an extensive reconditioning process involving meditation, exercise, and ritualistic self-mutilation. Every morning, as 13 wakes up, he dutifully takes a scalpel to his face, tracing out the lines before he makes the incisions, and removes a chunk of his face that’s replaced with a translucent, solid structure that heals the wound over and replaces the flesh beneath. Whatever the things are that 13’s shoving into his face, they alter the wiring of his being in a profound way—and, at least at first, he believes that the process is truly making him better.

While there’s obviously meaning baked into Perfect’s shots when the camera lingers on 13’s face as he draws out hashtags beneath his eyes in preparation for his latest alteration, it never exactly has a chance to amount to much, because the film mistakenly assumes that its shadowy, sumptuous cinematography can stand in for proper dialogue or subtext. Sarah (Courtney Eaton), another guest at the spa, acts as a kind of foil to 13; she drifts in and out of the film at random moments to remind the man that because she’s been at their new home longer than he has, she’s much farther along on the path to becoming a more evolved person than he is.

Flying Lotus’ intoxicatingly haunting score never lets you forget that Perfect is trying to build toward something profound and shocking about the human condition and the lengths we go to turn ourselves into things that we aren’t. Just as Vessel 13 can feel a twisted, primal darkness inside of him that threatens to claw its way out whenever he feels attracted to someone, you can feel Perfect’s desire to be equal parts heady and mind fuck-y.

But there’s a big difference between wanting to say something interesting and actually having something interesting to say. Unfortunately, Perfect never quite gets there.

Perfect hits theaters in NY on May 17 and LA on May 24 before being released on Breaker on June 21.


For more, make sure you’re following us on our new Instagram @io9dotcom.

5 Comments

Other Charles Pulliam-Moore's posts

Russian Sci-Fi Thriller Novel-Turned-Video Game Metro 2033 Is Becoming a Movie Russian Sci-Fi Thriller Novel-Turned-Video Game Metro 2033 Is Becoming a Movie

Before THQ’s Metro 2033 was a first person shooter, it was a novel written by Dmitry Glukhovsky about a nation of people forced to build a new underground civilization in subway stations and tunnels after a devastating nuclear war. Now, it’s set to become a live-action film , courtesy of Gazprom Media.Variety reports that after years of being approached...

It Chapter Two Features One Key Change to Pennywise's Homophobic Attack It Chapter Two Features One Key Change to Pennywise's Homophobic Attack

One of the biggest criticisms of Tommy Lee Wallace and Lawrence Cohen’s TV adaptation of Stephen King’s It from 1990 was the way it glossed over a key moment in Derry history when a gay man watches in terror as his partner is brutally beaten by a group of homophobes before they push him over the side of a...

Stan Lee’s Daughter Claims No One From Marvel or Disney Reached Out After His Death Stan Lee’s Daughter Claims No One From Marvel or Disney Reached Out After His Death

With the arc of Spider-Man’s cinematic future becoming the latest topic of conversation , everyone’s chiming in with their thoughts and opinions about the beef between Marvel Studios and Sony over the character. That includes J.C. Lee, the daughter of late Spider-Man co-creator Stan Lee.When TMZ recently asked the surviving Lee her thoughts about the multimillion-dollar Spider-spat , she...

Steven Universe: The Movie Is a Mindblowingly Heartfelt, Musical Masterpiece Steven Universe: The Movie Is a Mindblowingly Heartfelt, Musical Masterpiece

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFScenes from Steven Universe: The Movie.Image: Cartoon Networkio9 ReviewsReviews and critical analyses of fan-favorite movies, TV shows, comics, books, and more.  From the moment Steven Universe: The Movie ’s sumptuously-produced opening credits begin rolling, you can see how Rebecca Sugar really, really wasn’t being subtle earlier this year. She...

Suggested posts

Russian Sci-Fi Thriller Novel-Turned-Video Game Metro 2033 Is Becoming a Movie Russian Sci-Fi Thriller Novel-Turned-Video Game Metro 2033 Is Becoming a Movie

Before THQ’s Metro 2033 was a first person shooter, it was a novel written by Dmitry Glukhovsky about a nation of people forced to build a new underground civilization in subway stations and tunnels after a devastating nuclear war. Now, it’s set to become a live-action film , courtesy of Gazprom Media.Variety reports that after years of being approached...

4 Wild Gene Roddenberry Sci-Fi TV Projects That Had Nothing to Do With Star Trek 4 Wild Gene Roddenberry Sci-Fi TV Projects That Had Nothing to Do With Star Trek

He’s first and foremost the Star Trek guy, but the creative mind of Gene Roddenberry—born this week in 1921—also ventured far beyond the voyages of the Enterprise. A quartet of awesomely bizarre TV projects he made in the years between Star Trek and The Next Generation offers fascinating proof of this.Roddenberry, a military vet and former LAPD officer, started...

The New Ad Astra Trailer Amps Up Brad Pitt's Space Angst The New Ad Astra Trailer Amps Up Brad Pitt's Space Angst

Trailer FrenzyA special place to find the newest trailers for movies and TV shows you're craving.  As Brad Pitt’s Major Roy McBride ventures into deep space in James Gray’s upcoming space thriller Ad Astra , the famed legacy astronaut’s mind is pushed to its limits both by the unknowable darkness he literally finds himself surrounded by and the metaphorical darkness...

An Exclusive First Look at the Next Wave of Comixology Originals An Exclusive First Look at the Next Wave of Comixology Originals

San Diego Comic-Con only gave us a small snifter of what was to come out of Comixology’s latest round of creator-owned comics series—but io9 can exclusively reveal four more titles coming to the digital retailer’s line of original books.io9 is excited to reveal that the next wave of Comixology Originals will kick off next month. One of each title—all...

Here Are Your Hugo 2019 Award Winners Here Are Your Hugo 2019 Award Winners

Last night one of the biggest events in genre writing, the Hugo Awards , awarded creators at the 77th World Science Fiction Convention in Dublin, Ireland. Highlighting sci-fi and fantasy across films, TV, comics, criticism, fan works, and more, the Hugos are a celebration of some of the year’s finest—so get your notepad out and be ready to scribble...

Semen Smugglers, Spreadsheets, and Laughing to Death: Best Gizmodo Stories of the Week Semen Smugglers, Spreadsheets, and Laughing to Death: Best Gizmodo Stories of the Week

It’s been a weird one this week at Gizmodo, folks: From hacking buttplugs and realizing our dog photos have personally identifiable information in them to smuggled boar semen and an Arctic weather station hitting nearly 95 degrees Fahrenheit , we’ve been hard at work churning out the content you crave and that makes our heads hurt.Other fascinating stories from...

In This Sci-fi Horror Short, Only Control Can Hear You Scream In This Sci-fi Horror Short, Only Control Can Hear You Scream

As we’ve seen in films like The Martian or Gravity, being alone in space can be terrifying—especially when something unexpected comes knocking at the door. The sci-fi short Control centers around a woman on a deep-space mission who’s struggling to cope from the sudden loss of her crew partner, only to discover that she might not be alone after...

Joss Whedon's HBO Fantasy The Nevers Somehow Has Room for Even More Quirky Characters Joss Whedon's HBO Fantasy The Nevers Somehow Has Room for Even More Quirky Characters

Not even two weeks ago, Joss Whedon’s HBO series about a gaggle of Victorian-era ladies with superpowers announced the addition of a dozen actors, to go along with previously announced series star Laura Donnelly . That’s a rather huge ensemble, but The Nevers wasn’t done yet!Today, the show added six more names that’ll co-star with Donnelly, Olivia Williams, James...

After Event Horizon, Here Are More Sci-Fi Horror Movies That Should Get TV Adaptations After Event Horizon, Here Are More Sci-Fi Horror Movies That Should Get TV Adaptations

Stranger Things season three , which riffed on The Thing and The Blob (among others), was the latest testament to the enduring power of sci-fi horror—until we heard that Amazon was circling a series adaptation of Event Horizon . While the iron is hot, here are four more sci-fi horror titles perfect for TV translation.Pitch BlackDavid Twohy and Vin...

Intriguing Female Characters Highlight These 8 New Sci-Fi and Fantasy Shorts Intriguing Female Characters Highlight These 8 New Sci-Fi and Fantasy Shorts

Not all of the women in these new sci-fi and fantasy shorts—be they astronauts, fighter pilots, ambitious office workers, criminals, or just regular folks dealing with complicated emotions and surreal situations—are heroes. But isn’t life more interesting that way ? 1) Rendezvous With MarsDivya More and Mayukh Goswami created this animated film (shared online by Dust) about a woman...

Language