LOADING ...

The FDA Chose Not to Ban Breast Implants Linked to Cancer and Autoimmune Problems

Emily Alford May 03, 2019. 11 comments

One month after hearing from dozens of women who claimed they’d suffered from health problems linked to textured breast implants, including cancer and autoimmune issues, the FDA has decided not to ban the implants.

According to The Washington Post, a statement from the FDA says the organization, “does not believe that the product — a kind of textured implant — meets the legal standard for being banned at this time, based on available data and information.”

During a two-day panel hearing that took place in March, patients who’d had a rare lymphoma linked to implants, along with others who have suffered autoimmune or connective-tissue disease, testified that they hadn’t been adequately warned about risks before getting the implants. And though the FDA did not ban textured breast implants outright, they are considering much stronger warnings:

“Responding to such concerns, the agency said it is considering requiring implants to carry what’s called a boxed warning — the agency’s strongest safety warning. And it may require doctors and patients to sign checklists of risks to make sure women have the necessary information to make an informed decision.”

Worldwide, the FDA has identified 457 cases of breast implant-related lymphoma, as well as nine deaths. However, the organization noted that while textured implants account for as much as 80% of implants worldwide, they make up just 10% or less of breast implants in the U.S.

At the hearing, women also raised concerns of “breast implant illness” causing autoimmune issues such as pain, allergies, and fatigue. The FDA said it “‘doesn’t have definitive evidence demonstrating breast implants cause these symptoms,’” but added that evidence supports “that some women experience systemic symptoms that may resolve when their breast implants are removed” — and that women should be made aware of the risk before getting implants.”

The agency will also now require breast implant manufacturers to “file individual medical device reports for problems involving the products” rather than the previous system, which allowed them to file something called “alternative summary reporting” that made it less likely for reports of complications to become public.

The FDA has only banned two devices in its entire history: powdered surgeon’s gloves and prosthetic hair fibers.

11 Comments

Other Emily Alford's posts

There Is No Such Thing as 'Too Similar' When Publishers All Want the Same Book There Is No Such Thing as 'Too Similar' When Publishers All Want the Same Book

A few years ago, when I was shopping my now-shelved first novel, an industry insider told me to put the word “girls” in the title. “Girl” novels were big at the moment: Gone Girl, Girl on the Train, The Girls. But a few months later, I was told I had to change the title. There were too many novels...

Elton John Says He Once Hosted a Dinner Party Where Sylvester Stallone and Richard Gere Fought Over Princess Diana Elton John Says He Once Hosted a Dinner Party Where Sylvester Stallone and Richard Gere Fought Over Princess Diana

No, I did not simply plug names into a ’90s headline generator. According to Sir Elton John, Rambo and Edward Lewis once nearly engaged in fisticuffs over the heart of the people’s princess.This story gets even more delightfully ’90s when you factor in the fact that it was a party given by John and David Furnish for Disney chief...

Elizabeth Warren Campaign Fires Senior Staffer Following Allegations of 'Inappropriate Behavior' Elizabeth Warren Campaign Fires Senior Staffer Following Allegations of 'Inappropriate Behavior'

Rich McDaniel, a senior staffer on the Elizabeth Warren presidential campaign, has been fired amid allegations of “inappropriate behavior.”Politico reports that a person familiar with the campaign says that complaints about McDaniel’s behavior did not include allegations of sexual assault. To investigate the complaints, the campaign brought in an outside firm to interview staffers outside the presence of senior...

Epstein Accuser Alleges She Was Held Against Her Will on Victoria's Secret CEO Les Wexner's Compound Epstein Accuser Alleges She Was Held Against Her Will on Victoria's Secret CEO Les Wexner's Compound

An artist named Maria Farmer claims that armed guards employed by Victoria’s Secret billionaire Leslie Wexner allegedly kept her from leaving a house on Wexner’s Ohio compound for two months, during which time she was reportedly assaulted by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.According to Farmer, she was commissioned in the mid-90s to create two paintings for the film As...

Suggested posts

Ruth Bader Ginsburg Is Starting Out 2020 With Zero Cancer Ruth Bader Ginsburg Is Starting Out 2020 With Zero Cancer

Ruth Bader Ginsburg, shining star of the judiciary, has announced that she is “cancer free” after months of health problems.Ginsburg, who has scared the daylights out of us repeatedly in the last year with with lung cancer followed by a cancerous tumor on her pancreas, told CNN her 2020 is off to a promising start: “I’m cancer free. That’s...

Rep. John Lewis Has Stage IV Pancreatic Cancer Rep. John Lewis Has Stage IV Pancreatic Cancer

U.S. Representative and civil rights icon John Lewis announced on Sunday evening that he has stage IV pancreatic cancer. According to a statement on Lewis’s official website, the cancer was discovered during a routine medical examination. Lewis, 79, says he will continue to serve in office for as long as he can. “I have been in some kind of...

Exploring the Political Landscape of Cancer Exploring the Political Landscape of Cancer

“I didn’t know anything about having cancer,” Anne Boyer writes in her challenging new book The Undying: A Meditation on Modern Illness, “but I knew something about how to avoid telling a story.” There is, as Audre Lorde explained in The Cancer Journals, a curious silence around cancer. The silence doesn’t come from not talking, but is instead produced...

FDA Now Wants Breast Implant Manufacturers to Warn People of Potential Risks FDA Now Wants Breast Implant Manufacturers to Warn People of Potential Risks

After years of advising that it’s largely safe to get breast implants, the Food and Drug Administration is now recommending that breast implants come with stronger warnings about their possible health risks, ranging from fatigue to a rare form of cancer associated with a specific type of textured implant.On Wednesday, FDA officials released a guidance proposing that implant manufacturers...

Really Gonna Need Ruth Bader Ginsburg to Keep On Trucking Here Really Gonna Need Ruth Bader Ginsburg to Keep On Trucking Here

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has undergone another round of cancer treatments, NBC reports, and for the love of god and country I’m gonna need her to keep trooping through it. The Supreme Court released a statement that she has received radiation for a cancerous tumor on her pancreas, discovered July 31 at Sloan-Kittering Cancer Center in New...

FDA Now Wants Textured Breast Implants to Be Recalled FDA Now Wants Textured Breast Implants to Be Recalled

Almost three months after the Food and Drug Administration chose not to enact a wholesale ban of textured breast implants—a type of implant linked to a rare cancer—the agency has asked the breast implant maker Allergan to recall its textured implants currently available in the United States. According to the FDA, Allergan is “moving forward with a worldwide recall.”Worldwide,...

Doctors and Major Reproductive Health Organizations Just Took a Decisive Stand in Support of Self-Managed Abortion Doctors and Major Reproductive Health Organizations Just Took a Decisive Stand in Support of Self-Managed Abortion

In the spring of 2018, the Austria-based organization Aid Access started providing the two drugs needed for a medication-induced abortion, mifepristone and misoprostol, by mail to people in the United States. Its founder, a Dutch physician named Rebecca Gomperts—whose other organizations Women on Web and Women on Waves have worked to make abortion pills available online and by sea for...

Is CBD Over? Is CBD Over?

Have you ever eaten a CBD gummy , gingerly applied a CBD face mask , or ordered CBD-infused chicken enchiladas and wondered to yourself, “Why did I spend $28 on this? Is it even working?” Well, I have some good news for you: on Friday, the Food and Drug Administration is holding its first public hearing on the safety...

Great, Now Flour Might Kill Us Great, Now Flour Might Kill Us

In a world where measles is deadly again, and every surface will soon be coated by an impenetrable layer of drug-resistant fungus, pancakes were my only comfort. But nope, turns out flour is also diseased, and we all need to throw it away.The Centers for Disease Control has announced that 5-pound bags of Baker’s Corner All Purpose Flour could...

The FDA Has Finally Stopped the Sale of Pelvic Mesh The FDA Has Finally Stopped the Sale of Pelvic Mesh

After years of concern about the safety of vaginal mesh and several warnings that stopped short of an outright ban, the FDA has put a stop to its sale, which is often used to shore up weakened pelvic muscles that can lead to prolapse. The New York Times reported on the move, which affects the two companies still selling...

Language