LOADING ...

Jeff Kaplan Knows Some People Will Always Hate Overwatch's Meta

Nathan Grayson Jan 10, 2019. 17 comments

Metas of competitive games age less like fine wine and more like cottage cheese in a dumpster. When a meta’s overstayed its welcome, you know—because players make stink after stink after stink about it. That’s where Overwatch, with its unpopular “GOATS” meta, is at right now. Game director Jeff Kaplan, though, isn’t sure it’s possible to please the players who’ve been demanding change.

Speaking with Overwatch streamer Fran as part of the new Ana-themed Bastet promotion , the daddest man in game development said he thinks that GOATS—a popular high-level team composition that’s frustrated players due to its reliance on HP-heavy characters and sloggy strategies—has gone through the same life cycle as other metas, and whatever comes after it will, too.

“What’s inevitably gonna happen is, whether the meta changes or not, people will end up not liking the current meta. And I’ve already seen that happening. I’ve seen people say that GOATS is dead, and now it’s just double sniper, and that’s gonna be terrible,” he said, referring to a recent public test server update that significantly re-balanced a handful of characters, seemingly in an effort to make GOATS less effective.

“Or everyone is going to play McCree. At a certain point, what the hell do you people want?”

GOATS is a composition named after the pro team that first saw high-level success with it. The core strategy underlying GOATS is one of attrition: a team made up of tanks and area-of-effect-focused healers smashes itself against the enemy team until one of them breaks. Typically, heroes like Reinhardt, Zarya, D.Va, Brigitte, Lucio, and Moira are involved. Players dislike it because it’s both straightforward and limiting; the best way to beat it is to either mirror it or run a highly specific counter-composition.

Kaplan went on to jokingly suggest that people should just play Overwatch’s Mystery Heroes mode, in which everybody is assigned a random hero each time they spawn. But the calcification of the meta is no joke for Blizzard. Despite cries for a shake-up to the meta, it’s not something the development team can just change willy-nilly.

“Players will always want to play optimally,” Kaplan said. That means that either Blizzard would have to put in “some arbitrary system that forces the meta to change,” or rebalance the game with the idea of changing the meta. Barring that—or players figuring out something to finally counter GOATS—the status quo is what we’re stuck with.

Despite how vocal those players are, Kaplan feels like they represent a very particular subset of Overwatch’s fan base—the top ranks of players. GOATS isn’t as much of a problem for the average player, Kaplan said. “South of, let’s say, Diamond [rank], no one’s playing GOATS.” They might be picking the same characters because they’ve heard that GOATS is powerful, but they’re not actually executing the strategies that would cause that team to actually dominate.

It’s impossible, Kaplan said, for a game to ever be perfectly balanced, and even if Overwatch somehow was, he still believes high-level players would only ever pick a handful of optimal heroes. All the dev team can do, then, is focus on making a game that’s fun to play and watch for as many people as possible—diehards, casuals, and everyone in between.

“At a certain point, what do you expect to happen short of Mystery Heroes?” he said. “It’s not ever gonna be that. It’s not ever gonna be just any random six characters is always viable against any random other six heroes. That’s actually not the design of the game. The design of the game is that you look at the heroes and say, ‘This one is really cool to play as’ and things like ‘Imagine if I Nanoboost that character.’”

“Everyone’s gonna hate me for that answer,” Kaplan said, chuckling. “But I said it.”

17 Comments

Other Nathan Grayson's posts

The Big Con is a game is about conning people The Big Con is a game is about conning people

SteamedSteamed is dedicated to all things in and around Valve’s PC gaming service.  The Big Con is a game is about conning people. In the ‘90s. In it, you’ll “meet NPCs from all walks of life, rip them off, and sometimes help them if you feel like it.” You’ll be doing this in hopes of saving your mom, who owns...

New Overwatch Custom Mode Turns Sigma Into A Dodgeball Player New Overwatch Custom Mode Turns Sigma Into A Dodgeball Player

If you think about it, Overwatch’s new hero, Sigma, is kinda like a schoolkid—by which I mean he’s slow, and he likes to throw rocks. This, obviously, makes him an ideal competitor for a large-scale game of dodgeball.Overwatch player Pug has created a custom mode called “Sigma Dodgeball” (code: 0V80F), in which two teams of six Sigmas face off...

Fire Emblem Hacker Figures Out How To Have Tea Parties With Death Knight, Byleth, And Others Fire Emblem Hacker Figures Out How To Have Tea Parties With Death Knight, Byleth, And Others

When I fail to carry on a coherent conversation during a regular after-school hangout, I only have to worry about disappointing one of my precious anime children, all of who mean the whole entire world to me. On the other hand, if I bombed a tea party with the Death Knight, I’m worried that he might decide to live...

Dota 2 Fans' Reactions To Hong Kong Protests Take Over Twitch Chat Of $33 Million Tournament Dota 2 Fans' Reactions To Hong Kong Protests Take Over Twitch Chat Of $33 Million Tournament

We’re just days away from the biggest Dota 2 event of the year, the annual International tournament with its $33 million prize pool. Normally, this would be a time of celebration, but throughout the group stages leading into the August 20 main event, hardly anybody in Twitch chat has been talking about the games. Instead, fans have been in...

Suggested posts

'Shop Contest: Danny Trejo, Winners! 'Shop Contest: Danny Trejo, Winners!

Last week I asked you folks to create some images to honor and celebrate the man, myth, and legend himself, Danny Trejo. He recently saved a small child from a car crash, on top of other cool stuff.Our winning image this week comes from Add88 who has envisioned an alternate universe where Henry Cavil wasn’t playing Geralt in The...

New Overwatch Custom Mode Turns Sigma Into A Dodgeball Player New Overwatch Custom Mode Turns Sigma Into A Dodgeball Player

If you think about it, Overwatch’s new hero, Sigma, is kinda like a schoolkid—by which I mean he’s slow, and he likes to throw rocks. This, obviously, makes him an ideal competitor for a large-scale game of dodgeball.Overwatch player Pug has created a custom mode called “Sigma Dodgeball” (code: 0V80F), in which two teams of six Sigmas face off...

It's The End Of A Generation At This Year's Pokémon World Championships It's The End Of A Generation At This Year's Pokémon World Championships

At the 2019 Pokémon World Championships this weekend, trainers can choose any of the existing 807 known Pokémon to fight by their side. This is the last time they’ll be able to do so, at least in the near future.Earlier today, the Pokémon Company announced that Pokémon Sword and Shield will be the official games used for competitive play...

Cloud Saves On PS4 Have A Weird Limit Cloud Saves On PS4 Have A Weird Limit

Cloud saves are great. They keep your save data safe, providing backups for everything you’ve ever accomplished in a PS4 game. They also makes it easy to stop playing on one PS4 and pick up right where you left off on another. But PS4 cloud saves have a bizarre 1,000-file cap, and no one’s really sure why it exists.Twitter...

Halo Infinite Creative Director Leaves Company Halo Infinite Creative Director Leaves Company

Tim Longo, creative director for the upcoming Halo Infinite, left developer 343 Industries this week, Kotaku has learned. It’s part of a leadership shakeup that arrives late in the development of the next Halo game, which is scheduled for release in fall 2020.Longo, an industry veteran who also served as creative director for Halo 5, had moved to a...

Mortal Kombat 11 Is Letting A DJ Voice Sub-Zero And, Bless Him, He's Trying Mortal Kombat 11 Is Letting A DJ Voice Sub-Zero And, Bless Him, He's Trying

Renowned Belgian DJ Dimitri Vegas did the music for Mortal Kombat 11’s launch trailer. Next week, developer NetherRealm Studios is releasing a Sub-Zero skin featuring Vegas’ likeness, which is great. It also features Vegas’ voice, and that’s not so great.Mortal Kombat 11’s voice cast consists of proper professional voice actors with a firm handle on what they are doing...

The Chill YouTube Comments On Game Soundtracks Are A Pleasant Surprise The Chill YouTube Comments On Game Soundtracks Are A Pleasant Surprise

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFGIF: taia777 (YouTube)This hour-long video on YouTube, whose title roughly translates to “One hour corridor ‘Chrono Trigger,’” plays the same three-minute “Corridors of Time” track from the game over and over again. It has over 1 million views, and it also has one of the most pleasant comment...

Fire Emblem's Depiction Of Abuse Feels Real Fire Emblem's Depiction Of Abuse Feels Real

In Fire Emblem: Three Houses, there’s a character in Golden Deer house named Marianne. She’s so shy that she barely speaks. At first, I thought this was a confidence problem. I eagerly gave her gifts, not just to get to her next support rank and trigger a new conversation, but because being nice to someone who was clearly struggling felt...

What Are You Playing This Weekend? What Are You Playing This Weekend?

The weekend is for going to the farmer’s market to buy a million zucchinis, because that is the time of year it is. It’s also for playing video games.I’m excited to play more Breath of the Wild this weekend, during which time I hope to not stand around in the rain like an idiot again. I left my game...

The New Grandia HD Collection Is Pretty But Really Needs A Fast-Forward Button The New Grandia HD Collection Is Pretty But Really Needs A Fast-Forward Button

Grandia and its sequel, Grandia II, are both very good classic role-playing games, full of charm and adventure and spirit. They came out in 1997 and 2000, respectively. Even an HD remake isn’t enough to make up for that.Today, publisher Gungho Entertainment put out HD remakes of the first two Grandia games for Switch. The pack will cost you...

Language