LOADING ...

Jeff Kaplan Knows Some People Will Always Hate Overwatch's Meta

Nathan Grayson Jan 10, 2019. 17 comments

Metas of competitive games age less like fine wine and more like cottage cheese in a dumpster. When a meta’s overstayed its welcome, you know—because players make stink after stink after stink about it. That’s where Overwatch, with its unpopular “GOATS” meta, is at right now. Game director Jeff Kaplan, though, isn’t sure it’s possible to please the players who’ve been demanding change.

Speaking with Overwatch streamer Fran as part of the new Ana-themed Bastet promotion , the daddest man in game development said he thinks that GOATS—a popular high-level team composition that’s frustrated players due to its reliance on HP-heavy characters and sloggy strategies—has gone through the same life cycle as other metas, and whatever comes after it will, too.

“What’s inevitably gonna happen is, whether the meta changes or not, people will end up not liking the current meta. And I’ve already seen that happening. I’ve seen people say that GOATS is dead, and now it’s just double sniper, and that’s gonna be terrible,” he said, referring to a recent public test server update that significantly re-balanced a handful of characters, seemingly in an effort to make GOATS less effective.

“Or everyone is going to play McCree. At a certain point, what the hell do you people want?”

GOATS is a composition named after the pro team that first saw high-level success with it. The core strategy underlying GOATS is one of attrition: a team made up of tanks and area-of-effect-focused healers smashes itself against the enemy team until one of them breaks. Typically, heroes like Reinhardt, Zarya, D.Va, Brigitte, Lucio, and Moira are involved. Players dislike it because it’s both straightforward and limiting; the best way to beat it is to either mirror it or run a highly specific counter-composition.

Kaplan went on to jokingly suggest that people should just play Overwatch’s Mystery Heroes mode, in which everybody is assigned a random hero each time they spawn. But the calcification of the meta is no joke for Blizzard. Despite cries for a shake-up to the meta, it’s not something the development team can just change willy-nilly.

“Players will always want to play optimally,” Kaplan said. That means that either Blizzard would have to put in “some arbitrary system that forces the meta to change,” or rebalance the game with the idea of changing the meta. Barring that—or players figuring out something to finally counter GOATS—the status quo is what we’re stuck with.

Despite how vocal those players are, Kaplan feels like they represent a very particular subset of Overwatch’s fan base—the top ranks of players. GOATS isn’t as much of a problem for the average player, Kaplan said. “South of, let’s say, Diamond [rank], no one’s playing GOATS.” They might be picking the same characters because they’ve heard that GOATS is powerful, but they’re not actually executing the strategies that would cause that team to actually dominate.

It’s impossible, Kaplan said, for a game to ever be perfectly balanced, and even if Overwatch somehow was, he still believes high-level players would only ever pick a handful of optimal heroes. All the dev team can do, then, is focus on making a game that’s fun to play and watch for as many people as possible—diehards, casuals, and everyone in between.

“At a certain point, what do you expect to happen short of Mystery Heroes?” he said. “It’s not ever gonna be that. It’s not ever gonna be just any random six characters is always viable against any random other six heroes. That’s actually not the design of the game. The design of the game is that you look at the heroes and say, ‘This one is really cool to play as’ and things like ‘Imagine if I Nanoboost that character.’”

“Everyone’s gonna hate me for that answer,” Kaplan said, chuckling. “But I said it.”

17 Comments

Other Nathan Grayson's posts

Overwatch Glitch Allows All Heroes To Fly Overwatch Glitch Allows All Heroes To Fly

Unlike most first-person shooters, Overwatch is not opposed to allowing some heroes to fly. Pharah rockets up and bonks her head on the sky’s ceiling. Sigma soars above the battlefield on an invisible cloud of psychic energy during his ult. Zenyatta hovers and should never be allowed to walk. Real flight for everyone, though, is a recipe for chaos....

Popular WoW Streamer Hires YouTubers Who Leeched Off His Stream To Run Official Channel Popular WoW Streamer Hires YouTubers Who Leeched Off His Stream To Run Official Channel

If you search any popular Twitch streamer’s name on YouTube, you’ll find countless videos scraped from their streams. Of these, some will likely come from the streamer, but many are the product of users who upload content that is not, strictly speaking, theirs.Recent YouTube changes, however, are apparently making that more difficult. Instead of cheering YouTube leeches’ demise, WoW...

Valve Removes Nazi Steam Profiles After German Complaints Valve Removes Nazi Steam Profiles After German Complaints

SteamedSteamedSteamed is dedicated to all things in and around Valve’s PC gaming service.Prev NextView All Far-right groups that often employed Nazi-inspired language have long been able to create ugly little dens on Steam without facing too much resistance. Last year, Valve quietly deleted many hate groups in the wake of sustained reporting from publications like Vice, but Steam’s owners...

The First Epic Exclusives Are Now Arriving On Steam The First Epic Exclusives Are Now Arriving On Steam

SteamedSteamedSteamed is dedicated to all things in and around Valve’s PC gaming service.Prev NextView All In the annals of holiday lore it said that, every year, after circling the globe on a carpet-sized copy of Death Stranding, Geoff Keighley touches down for the briefest of moments in December to host The Game Awards. Last year, this led to an...

Suggested posts

Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Is Coming Back With A Brand New Game Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Is Coming Back With A Brand New Game

A spiritual successor to 2001’s Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance is coming next year, Wizards of the Coast announced tonight at the Game Awards.Called Dark Alliance, the action role-playing game is based on Dungeons & Dragons’ Forgotten Realms campaign and will follow the exploits of the dark elf Drizzt Do’Urden, created by fantasy writer R. A. Salvatore. Like the original...

Watch The 2019 Game Awards Here Watch The 2019 Game Awards Here

Here we are again: The Game Awards, in which new game reveals and occasional shenanigans are interspersed with people winning things. Join us, won’t you?Things kick off at 8:30 Eastern. You can watch on YouTube, below, or on Twitch, Mixer, Twitter, or Steam.

The Contents Of The Secret $375 Inside Collector’s Edition Have Been Revealed, And The Contents Of The Secret $375 Inside Collector’s Edition Have Been Revealed, And

In March of last year, iam8bit and developer Playdead announced a very special collector’s edition for indie adventure game Inside. The $375 box contains a PlayStation 4 copy of the game, Steam codes for Inside and Limbo, and a secret something from sex-mannequin maker Realdoll. Now that the collector’s editions are about to ship, iam8bit has revealed the abomination...

Overwatch Glitch Allows All Heroes To Fly Overwatch Glitch Allows All Heroes To Fly

Unlike most first-person shooters, Overwatch is not opposed to allowing some heroes to fly. Pharah rockets up and bonks her head on the sky’s ceiling. Sigma soars above the battlefield on an invisible cloud of psychic energy during his ult. Zenyatta hovers and should never be allowed to walk. Real flight for everyone, though, is a recipe for chaos....

GTA Online's Latest Update Adds A Huge New Heist GTA Online's Latest Update Adds A Huge New Heist

Grand Theft Auto Online got a new heist today, a rare and wonderful occurrence. The Diamond Casino Heist update includes a new heist, as well as new music, weapons, collectibles, and balance changes that make it harder to grief other players. The big star of this new update is, of course, the heist. After the events that took place...

Season Of Dawn Is A Nice Break From The Destiny 2 Power Grind Season Of Dawn Is A Nice Break From The Destiny 2 Power Grind

BungiDestiny 2’s latest season features Saint-14, a legendary Titan whom players have been eager to meet. The only catch is that they’ll have to spend a lot of time doing boring stuff before they get to learn more about him.Season of Dawn, which went live on December 10, begins with the return of Osiris, Destiny 2’s Warlock of mystery,...

Black Desert Mobile Is Out Globally Today, And It's Good Black Desert Mobile Is Out Globally Today, And It's Good

Black Desert, the fantasy online role-playing game with the character creator we wouldn’t shut up about a few years back, started on PC, then jumped to Xbox One and PlayStation 4 . Last year, developer Pearl Abyss released a free-to-play mobile version in Korea, Japan, and Taiwan. Starting today, everybody can play the tablet-taxing MMO on iOS and Android,...

Valve Removes Nazi Steam Profiles After German Complaints Valve Removes Nazi Steam Profiles After German Complaints

SteamedSteamedSteamed is dedicated to all things in and around Valve’s PC gaming service.Prev NextView All Far-right groups that often employed Nazi-inspired language have long been able to create ugly little dens on Steam without facing too much resistance. Last year, Valve quietly deleted many hate groups in the wake of sustained reporting from publications like Vice, but Steam’s owners...

Forza Horizon 4 Is Getting A 72-Car Battle Royale Mode Forza Horizon 4 Is Getting A 72-Car Battle Royale Mode

Racing through Britain’s pastoral countryside is about to become a matter of life and death.Forza Horizon 4’s December 12 update will add the series’ first-ever battle royale mode, called Eliminator, Playground Games announced during its developer livestream today. The new mode pits 72 players against one another in a race to the center of an open-air arena as a...

Mona Lisa Too Expensive? Now You Can Own Johnny Five Aces' Original Concept Art Mona Lisa Too Expensive? Now You Can Own Johnny Five Aces' Original Concept Art

Internet historians, here’s your chance to own your own piece of internet history: concept art of Johnny Five Aces, main character of the legendarily shitty game concept The Zybourne Clock.The Zybourne Clock was an idea for a steampunk game about time travel proposed in 2003 in the forums of Something Awful, comedy website with an influential and infamous community....

Language