LOADING ...

That's Not My Arthur Morgan

Luke Plunkett Nov 30, 2018. 20 comments

Here’s a thing I’ve noticed while watching other people play Red Dead Redemption 2: there’s an Arthur Morgan on the screen, who looks like Arthur Morgan and sounds like Arthur Morgan, but isn’t my Arthur Morgan.

I know it’s the same character, but it’s also not, and that never sits right with me. I call it the Geralt-Morgan Effect.

That’s because I get the same feeling watching people play The Witcher 3. There can be a Geralt on the screen doing the same things mine did, knockin’boots and rubbin’ oils, but something feels off about it because that’s not what my Geralt looked like.

It’s as though I was watching Invasion of the Body Snatchers. Only instead of aliens swooping in and replacing everyone in my town with off-putting clones, it was my friends and colleagues giving Geralt stupid haircuts that, to me and my understanding/love of the character, he would never dream of.

Both Red Dead Redemption 2 and The Witcher 3 exist in this strange space where you’re given a pre-written, pre-voiced character whose base appearance can’t be changed. Everyone’s Arthur Morgan sounds like Roger Clark, they’ve got the same steely eyes and the same weathered face.

So there’s a shared experience there. Like Lara Croft, or Master Chief, Arthur Morgan has a name, a voice and a story. We’re not building our own hero here, we’re taking charge of one that had already been made and just pushing him through a storyline. What’s more, his character is written so as to account for almost any action you take in this game: whether you play like a rogue or a gentleman, you’ll still be forced to both save and murder people, and so no matter your actions Arthur Morgan’s story will be the same for everyone.

Yet outside of these core parameters, and unlike Lara Croft or Master Chief, we can still make significant changes. We can give Arthur haircuts, shave his facial hair and dress him up in a wide variety of clothes. This might seem superficial, trivial even, but I’ve found it has a huge impact on how we perceive these characters.

My Arthur Morgan, gruff and practical but also grudgingly accepting of the onset of the modern age, is reliably basic. He wears a white shirt with suspenders, plain spurs and boots and a tattered old hat. He sports a moustache that is rarely kept clean-shaven, and a slicked-back haircut that’s more about practicality than style.

I dress him like that because that’s what I think he’s like. Arthur isn’t my character, so whenever it comes time to select clothes in the game I find myself picking what I think Arthur would pick, not what I’d opt for if given a blank slate. And Arthur doesn’t seem like a guy who would willingly opt for a fancy suit, or extravagant sideburns.

This is dumb, I know, but I’m a singleplayer obsessive who once immersed in an adventure is immersed. There’s an odd kind of compromise at play here, where a character I didn’t create is still somehow becoming mine through the way I customise them.

While loads of games let you customise existing characters, I think there’s a set of circumstances that you only find in these two games that allow for this sensation.

Both are exceptionally long, dense games, meaning we get to spend a lot of time with these guys. Both characters are exceptionally well-written and acted, which helps us relate to them and makes them start to feel a little more “real”. And both give us the means to customise the character’s appearance without changing stuff like body shape and skin colour.

So while Rockstar’s own Grand Theft Auto V let you edit the character’s appearance, their lack of depth, and the way the game had you jumping between each star, meant we never really got to know them, so those changes didn’t mean much. And while Assassin’s Creed Odyssey might seemingly meet all the criteria I just listed, the fact you can’t customise Kassandra’s (or Alexios’) face and hair keeps them looking the same—albeit with some wardrobe disagreements—across everyone’s experience.

I’m not saying this is a problem. Unless it’s maybe a problem for me, someone who reading back over this realises I might just be a little too into these big singleplayer adventures. And I’m fully aware that just as I’m finding someone else’s Arthur Morgan looking strange, they’d just as likely look at mine and think, no, this isn’t right either.

I just find it interesting that we’re at a point now with some video games where you can grow to know and love a character so much that even the slightest changes to their physical appearance, as much as any decisions you might make during gameplay, can have a big impact on the way that character is perceived.

20 Comments

Other Luke Plunkett's posts

Pick Up That Can Pick Up That Can

Fine Art[Fine Art](https://kotaku.com/c/fine-art) is a celebration of the work of video game artists, showcasing the best of both their professional and personal portfolios. If you’re in the business and have some art you’d like to share, [get in touch!](mailto:plunkett@kotaku.com)  Alex Nice is an artist who has worked on stuff like Pacific Rim and John Wick 3.You can see more of...

Ignored By Nintendo, Brazilian Fans Film Their Own Nintendo Direct Ignored By Nintendo, Brazilian Fans Film Their Own Nintendo Direct

If you want something done, you gotta do it yourself.As USGamer report, a group of Brazilian Nintendo fans, fed up with the way the company has withdrawn from the market (which has left them paying big import prices for games and hardware), decided to team up and record their own Nintendo Direct.Led by the hard work of Rodrigo Coelho...

Our Favorite Photos From YetiCon, Canada's Mountain Cosplay Party Our Favorite Photos From YetiCon, Canada's Mountain Cosplay Party

Cosplay GalleryA showcase of some of the best photos and video from cosplay events around the world. Credits provided where possible, but if we've missed something [let us know and we can add](mailto:plunkett@kotaku.com)!  YetiCon, a show held every year in Canada’s Blue Mountains, is a cosplay con with a big focus on adventure stuff, ranging from toboggan rides to...drinking by the...

The Tracks Lead Off In This Direction The Tracks Lead Off In This Direction

Fine Art[Fine Art](https://kotaku.com/c/fine-art) is a celebration of the work of video game artists, showcasing the best of both their professional and personal portfolios. If you’re in the business and have some art you’d like to share, [get in touch!](mailto:plunkett@kotaku.com)  Katya Gudkina is an artist at Bethesda, the developers of the Fallout and Elder Scrolls series.You can see more of Gudkina’s...

Suggested posts

British Website Forced To Pay $1.3 Million Over Red Dead Redemption 2 Leak British Website Forced To Pay $1.3 Million Over Red Dead Redemption 2 Leak

The British website TrustedReviews today pulled an article, apologized to publisher Take-Two Games, and said it was donating 1 million pounds ($1.3 million) to charity after publishing leaked information about Red Dead Redemption 2 in February of this year. It’s a radical move that raises serious questions about editorial independence and legal threats against the press.TrustedReviews, which is owned...

T-Posing Away From T-Rex T-Posing Away From T-Rex

Today Highlight Reel we have Red Dead horses, more Hitman 2 briefcase magic, international Battlefield V headshots, dinosaurs, and much more!Watch the video then talk about your favorite highlight in the comments below. Be sure to check out, like, and share the original videos via the links below. Subscribe to Kotaku on YouTube for more! Catch up on all the...

Red Dead Online's New Update Is A Good Start Red Dead Online's New Update Is A Good Start

After weeks of teasing and hyping, the latest and biggest Red Dead Online update went live today. The update adds new fashion items, changes how bounties work, rebalances gameplay and fixes numerous bugs. It’s a good update with some great improvements, but it might not be enough for fans looking to come back. One of the biggest new changes...

Red Dead Online's Next Update Will Combat Griefing, Rebalance Weapons  Red Dead Online's Next Update Will Combat Griefing, Rebalance Weapons 

Red Dead Online will be receiving a large update on February 26th, Rockstar Games announced today. This update will add new daily challenges and rebalance some weapons. It will also implement some of the changes Rockstar first revealed back in January. In their news post, they explained in more detail how many of these changes will work and how...

Rockstar Outlines How It Plans To Fix Some Of Red Dead Online’s Problems Rockstar Outlines How It Plans To Fix Some Of Red Dead Online’s Problems

Red Dead Online didn’t have a great launch. The multiplayer mode of Red Dead Redemption 2 was made available to players last year in late November via a staggered release window. Once players had access to RDO, they found overpriced guns, a broken economy , and a lack of content. Some player also encountered griefers and trolls every time...

Red Dead Cowboy Brings Gun To Knife Game Red Dead Cowboy Brings Gun To Knife Game

Today on Highlight Reel we have Red Dead Redemption 2 knife games, falling cowpokes, ancient bear gladiators, flying salarymen, and much more! Watch the video then talk about your favorite highlight in the comments below. Be sure to check out, like, and share the original videos via the links below. Subscribe to Kotaku on YouTube for more! Catch up on...

Red Dead Redemption 2 Horse Is Finally Free...Oh No Red Dead Redemption 2 Horse Is Finally Free...Oh No

Today on Highlight Reel we have teleporting NFL players, cowboy weirdness, and much more!Watch the video then talk about your favorite highlight in the comments below. Be sure to check out, like, and share the original videos via the links below. Subscribe to Kotaku on YouTube for more! Catch up on all the episodes on the Highlight Reel Youtube playlist!COD:BO4...

Red Dead Redemption 2 Players Are Using Canoes To Escape The World Red Dead Redemption 2 Players Are Using Canoes To Escape The World

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFGIF: Basement Gamer Bros (YouTube)The world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is large. Though after you spend enough time running around the deserts and swamps of RDR2, you might want to take a vacation. Maybe go visit a new exotic land? Some crafty players have figured out how...

Call Of Duty Team Eliminated With One Bullet Call Of Duty Team Eliminated With One Bullet

Today on Highlight Reel we have Kinect-enabled Smash, horse crap gifts, friendly Resident Evil 2 zombies, and much more!Watch the video then talk about your favorite highlight in the comments below. Be sure to check out, like, and share the original videos via the links below. Subscribe to Kotaku on YouTube for more! Catch up on all the episodes on...

Red Dead Man Can't Keep Head On Straight Red Dead Man Can't Keep Head On Straight

Today on Highlight Reel we have well-meaning horses, head-turners, and much more!Watch the video then talk about your favorite highlight in the comments below. Be sure to check out, like, and share the original videos via the links below. Subscribe to Kotaku on YouTube for more! Catch up on all the episodes on the Highlight Reel Youtube playlist!Ring of Elysium...

Language