LOADING ...

The Kids’ Climate Case Will Not Be Derailed, Trial Begins in Two Weeks

Brian Kahn Oct 16, 2018. 2 comments

On Monday, a judge ruled that while Donald Trump can’t be named as defendant in the kids climate lawsuit, the trial will go on. It sets up a historic courtroom showdown in two weeks that will pit youths’ constitutional rights to a stable climate against the federal government and its inaction on climate change.

The ruling comes after the latest in a salvo of attempts by the federal government to derail the suit. Past efforts have by and large failed, but the new motions found some results. The government argued that the president should be taken off the case as a defendant, saying he wasn’t essential to providing the plaintiffs’ relief. It also argued the scope of the case was too wide, and asked yet again for the whole case to get dismissed.

On the Trump front, the climate denier in chief is off the hook for now. In her decision, Judge Ann Aiken agreed with the government that Trump isn’t essential to the case since other parts of the federal government could provide the relief the 21 youth plaintiffs are seeking. Aiken didn’t, however, rule out that Trump’s name could be added back to the suit in the future.

The judge also narrowed the scope of suit by tossing out a part which was tied to the Ninth Amendment and rights to be sustained by the climate system. But the judge allowed the kids’ central argument—that climate change and its attendant impacts will deprive them of the right to life, liberty, and property protected under the Fifth Amendment—to proceed.

“At this stage, federal defendants have offered no legal or factual rationale significantly different from those offered in their previous motion to dismiss,” Aiken wrote, saying the suit would go to trial on October 29.

The high-profile suit began in federal court in 2015, naming then-President Barack Obama as a defendant. His administration tried to get the suit dismissed to no avail. When Trump took office two years ago, the defendant named in the suit changed, but the efforts to get it thrown out didn’t.

And the attempts to chip away at the case continue as the trial date looms. E&E News reports the government is now attempting to limit expert testimony from climate scientists. None of this appears to have taken wind out of the plaintiffs’ sails, though.

“Having contributed extensive personal testimony and research to help develop our case’s factual record over the past several years, I am confident that our arguments on the remaining disputed issues will ultimately prevail in court,” Alex Loznak, one of plaintiffs, said in a statement. “We still need a full and fair trial to prove our case. October 29, here we come!”

2 Comments

Other Brian Kahn's posts

Big Oil Is Scared Big Oil Is Scared

Here is a simple truth: The world cannot build more fossil fuel infrastructure and have a habitable climate. Science bears this out , and a growing number of people around the world are putting their bodies on the line in the service of said science and habitable climate as well as protecting other natural resources.This has put them in...

Elizabeth Warren's Latest Plan Tackles U.S. Injustices Against Tribes and Their Lands Elizabeth Warren's Latest Plan Tackles U.S. Injustices Against Tribes and Their Lands

Elizabeth Warren is a woman of many plans, but on Friday the United States senator and Democratic presidential candidate released one of her most detailed ones yet. The plan focuses on what she would do as president to uplift indigenous people and tribes across the U.S. It includes sweeping new protections for tribal lands, restoring Bears Ears National Monument...

Here's a Bunch of Stuff the U.S. Would Get If Donald Trump Bought Greenland Here's a Bunch of Stuff the U.S. Would Get If Donald Trump Bought Greenland

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFIllustration: G/O Media/APDonald Trump wants to buy Greenland . Okay then.The Wall Street Journal broke the news Thursday afternoon that our big real estate boy in the White House has floated the idea to multiple aides that the U.S. should purchase the world’s largest island. This is, to...

Invasive Pests Are Devastating American Forests at an Alarming Rate Invasive Pests Are Devastating American Forests at an Alarming Rate

New findings show that invasive species are wiping out trees across the U.S., devastating forests and their ability to store carbon. That’s particularly bad news in light of the worsening climate crisis.Turning the tide against climate change will need to involve tending to forests and maximizing their ability to suck up and store carbon in the trees and soil....

Suggested posts

The Hunt's Director Says the Movie Was Never Meant to Divide Audiences The Hunt's Director Says the Movie Was Never Meant to Divide Audiences

In the wake of three back-to-back mass shootings and criticism from Donald Trump, Universal ultimately decided to shelve Craig Zobel’s The Hunt . The film was obviously meant to provoke audiences by tapping into our current political climate, but in a new interview, Zobel explained how he never meant for the film to be anything other than a piece...

Big Oil Is Scared Big Oil Is Scared

Here is a simple truth: The world cannot build more fossil fuel infrastructure and have a habitable climate. Science bears this out , and a growing number of people around the world are putting their bodies on the line in the service of said science and habitable climate as well as protecting other natural resources.This has put them in...

Hurricanes and Climate Change Might Make Spiders More Aggressive Hurricanes and Climate Change Might Make Spiders More Aggressive

Hurricanes could make spider colonies more aggressive over time, according to a new paper. Let’s add “avoiding extra-evil spider colonies” to our list of reasons to fight climate change, please and thanks.It’s obvious that hurricanes cause damage, but it’s hard to study how that damage might impact the evolution of the animals that survive the storm. Given that some...

Semen Smugglers, Spreadsheets, and Laughing to Death: Best Gizmodo Stories of the Week Semen Smugglers, Spreadsheets, and Laughing to Death: Best Gizmodo Stories of the Week

It’s been a weird one this week at Gizmodo, folks: From hacking buttplugs and realizing our dog photos have personally identifiable information in them to smuggled boar semen and an Arctic weather station hitting nearly 95 degrees Fahrenheit , we’ve been hard at work churning out the content you crave and that makes our heads hurt.Other fascinating stories from...

Icelanders Mourn Loss of Okjökull Glacier With Ceremony, Plaque Icelanders Mourn Loss of Okjökull Glacier With Ceremony, Plaque

Politicians, scientists, and others gathered in Borgarfjörður, Iceland, northeast of Reykjavik on Sunday to mourn the loss of the Okjökull glacier, laying a plaque warning of the impact of climate change, the BBC reported.Okjökull, along with many other Icelandic glaciers, took serious hits from warming summers over the past two decades. It was officially declared inactive by glaciologist Oddur...

Art Spiegelman Withdrew His Introduction to a Marvel Comics Collection After Publisher Tried to Remove His Anti-Trump Comments Art Spiegelman Withdrew His Introduction to a Marvel Comics Collection After Publisher Tried to Remove His Anti-Trump Comments

Pullitzer Prize-winning creator of Maus  Art Spiegelman was slated to write the introduction to a new Marvel collection, Marvel The Golden Age 1939-1949 , but pulled his work after Marvel wanted him to remove a disparaging reference to Donald Trump. As reported by Newsweek, Spiegelman, in an essay discussing the political background of Marvel’s offerings during and right after...

Portugal Is Using Goats to Prepare for Wildfires, But There's Not Enough Shepherds Portugal Is Using Goats to Prepare for Wildfires, But There's Not Enough Shepherds

Portugal, which has been ravaged by wildfires of increasing severity and duration in the era of climate change, is turning back to the goat to clear underbrush in the hopes of limiting potential fuel sources for the blazes, the New York Times reported on Saturday.One issue? A critical shortage of goatherds and shepherds in the ongoing pilot program dedicated...

Elizabeth Warren's Latest Plan Tackles U.S. Injustices Against Tribes and Their Lands Elizabeth Warren's Latest Plan Tackles U.S. Injustices Against Tribes and Their Lands

Elizabeth Warren is a woman of many plans, but on Friday the United States senator and Democratic presidential candidate released one of her most detailed ones yet. The plan focuses on what she would do as president to uplift indigenous people and tribes across the U.S. It includes sweeping new protections for tribal lands, restoring Bears Ears National Monument...

Here's a Bunch of Stuff the U.S. Would Get If Donald Trump Bought Greenland Here's a Bunch of Stuff the U.S. Would Get If Donald Trump Bought Greenland

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFIllustration: G/O Media/APDonald Trump wants to buy Greenland . Okay then.The Wall Street Journal broke the news Thursday afternoon that our big real estate boy in the White House has floated the idea to multiple aides that the U.S. should purchase the world’s largest island. This is, to...

La ultima ocurrencia de Trump: comprar Groenlandia La ultima ocurrencia de Trump: comprar Groenlandia

Según una historia publicada por el Wall Street Journal este jueves y de la que se han hecho eco otros medios, parece que el presidente Donald Trump le ha pedido en repetidas ocasiones a sus ayudantes que averigüen si es posible comprar Groenlandia. Parece una historia sacada de El Mundo Today, pero no. Esto es un extracto del propio...

Language