LOADING ...

Here's the Streaming Video Service That's the Best Bargain for Your Money

Nick Douglas Sep 28, 2018. 21 comments

It feels as if Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime want you to be confused about how many titles they offer at any given time. Streaming video aggregator Reelgood (a search engine and launcher for all your streaming video accounts) has been tracking their libraries for years, noticing things like Netflix’s shrinking and growing catalog. Now they’ve released an analysis of which streaming service gives you the biggest “bang for your buck”—the most worthwhile shows and movies per subscription dollar.

This is different from which service has the most titles overall. Amazon Prime Video has over 10,000 movies, but many of them are obscure titles you’ll never actually want to watch. Reelgood looked for just the 20,000 most popular shows and movies among its users, minus any that were very poorly rated on IMDb. Out of this crap-free selection, Reelgood analyzed which services performed best.

Between the top five streaming services—Netflix, Prime Video, Hulu, HBO, and Showtime—Reelgood found that Prime Video and Netflix were about tied for quality movies, with a thousand each, with Hulu coming in third at under 500. But for quality TV shows, Hulu won with 749, followed by Netflix at 495.

Then Reelgood applied the cost of each service, to figure out which services offer the most “quality titles per dollar.” With price factored in, Prime Video wins at movies, and Hulu wins at TV shows:

So if you can only afford one streaming service, and you only care about how many decent movies or shows you get, choose Prime Video or Hulu, respectively.

Of course, if you’re a huge fan of Game of Thrones and Veep, or of Stranger Things and Bojack Horseman, then it’s not so simple. But in general, better to pay for Hulu and borrow your neighbor’s HBO password—or buy a couple shows a la carte—than vice versa.

For now, anyway. HBO’s new owner wants the network to make more original shows and become more of a must-have. In light of a chart like this, that makes sense.

Reelgood, an independent service running on VC funding, tells Lifehacker they have no financial ties to any streaming services.

Which Streaming Service Is The Best Bang For Your Buck? | Reelgood

21 Comments

Other Nick Douglas's posts

How to Send Email Newsletters to Instapaper How to Send Email Newsletters to Instapaper

Email newsletters are trendy right now, but they can be a lot. If newsletters are clogging up your inbox, here’s how to send them to Instapaper. (Plus a workaround for Pocket.) Read It Later Showdown: Pocket vs. Instapaper When it comes to “read it later” services that let you save articles today to read when you have…Read more Read...

Sign Up for Free Trials With DoNotPay Sign Up for Free Trials With DoNotPay

iOS: When you sign up for a free trial with your credit card, there’s a risk that you’ll forget to cancel, and Netflix or Spotify or Audible or HBO will start charging you monthly. Some services make it hard to cancel, and some, like MoviePass , even “uncancel” you. There’s a new tool for power users who want to...

What's the Most Important Local Law in Your City? What's the Most Important Local Law in Your City?

Hack Your CityEach Monday we ask you for your best city tips: driving tips, restaurant recs, things to do, and any other advice for visitors and locals. Sometimes the weekly topic is a specific city; other times it's an aspect of all cities, so everyone can participate.  You can’t turn right on red in New York City (or smoke in...

Watch the Best Episodes of a TV Series With ShowSkimmer Watch the Best Episodes of a TV Series With ShowSkimmer

The site ShowSkimmer is a new tool for finding the best episodes of a TV show. Search for a series, and ShowSkimmer will list the best 5, 10, 25, or 50 episodes, in chronological order. It’s a great way to watch a series while skipping all the forgettable episodes—which is especially good for long-running sitcoms with light plots and...

Suggested posts

What's Coming and Going From Netflix the Week of July 22, 2019 What's Coming and Going From Netflix the Week of July 22, 2019

Let’s start of the week with a confession: I never bothered seeing Inglourious Basterds, and I’ve been quietly irritated by the spelling of the title since it first came out in 2009. I assume it’s a reference to something within the movie, but who’s to say? Not me! Maybe this month I’ll finally find out. Quentin Tarantino’s Nazi-killing period...

This Chrome Extension Makes Netflix Look Like a Conference Call This Chrome Extension Makes Netflix Look Like a Conference Call

Sometimes you want to watch Netflix, but need that watching to be on the discrete side. Or instance, maybe it would help if your computer’s screen looked like you were on a conference call talking to people in another office rather than watch The Office.Netflix Hangouts is a Chrome extension that does just that.Once installed, the extension loads up...

How to Stream the Veronica Mars Movie Before Binging Season 4 How to Stream the Veronica Mars Movie Before Binging Season 4

Hulu released season 4 of Veronica Mars Friday, a week early, as a birthday present for its star Kristin Bell. Her birthday was July 18th. If you’re all caught up, you can stream that now through the service. If you’re not all caught up and want to catch up on the most recent release from the series, you can...

Watch the Best Episodes of a TV Series With ShowSkimmer Watch the Best Episodes of a TV Series With ShowSkimmer

The site ShowSkimmer is a new tool for finding the best episodes of a TV show. Search for a series, and ShowSkimmer will list the best 5, 10, 25, or 50 episodes, in chronological order. It’s a great way to watch a series while skipping all the forgettable episodes—which is especially good for long-running sitcoms with light plots and...

What Your Kid Can Learn From BBC’s 'Sarah & Duck' What Your Kid Can Learn From BBC’s 'Sarah & Duck'

In the British cartoon Sarah & Duck, Sarah is a girl who lives with her best friend, a mallard named Duck. Their home is devoid of adults except the omnipresent narrator/possible dad. Each short episode follows the pair through both mundane activities (like making a cake) and fantastical scenarios (like the cake batter coming to life to coach them...

What's Coming and Going From Netflix the Week of July 15, 2019 What's Coming and Going From Netflix the Week of July 15, 2019

Jerry Seinfeld is back behind the wheel of a lot of fancy cars (and it looks like one moped?) as the next installment of Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee drops on Friday. Bridget Everett, Eddie Murphy, Matthew Broderick, Jamie Foxx and Seth Rogen are all part of the innocuous, low-commitment froth this time around. If you prefer something with...

Join Our MoviePass Support Group Join Our MoviePass Support Group

MoviePass, the service that lets you watch a different amount of movies under a different set of restrictions each month, recently switched to a plan of three movies per month. What will happen to the MoviePass clubs that would go see movies together? How will they fare in a world where MoviePass kind of sucks? Let’s discuss below, in...

You Can Get Amazon Prime Music Unlimited For Free For 3 Months Right Now You Can Get Amazon Prime Music Unlimited For Free For 3 Months Right Now

If you’ve been wanting to give Amazon Prime Music a try, now might be one of the best times to sign up.Amazon is currently offering three months of the streaming music service for free, provided you haven’t used the service before. The promotion is valid between now and May 14th, 2019. After the three months, you’ll be charged $9.99...

Learn Another Language While Watching Netflix Using This App Learn Another Language While Watching Netflix Using This App

Learning a new language is hard. After eight years of French, I was an abysmal failure at the language until I spent a month in the country using it regularly. There’s something about seeing words and phrases used in context that makes them a lot easier to understand than just reading them in a textbook.Lingvo is an app that...

What's Coming and Going From Netflix the Week of December 31, 2018 What's Coming and Going From Netflix the Week of December 31, 2018

The end of year offerings from Netflix were grim, so it is with pleasure that I welcome the bumper crop of entertainment in this week’s harvest. We’ve got the full complement of Indiana Jones flicks arriving on Tuesday (I see we are now calling the first installment “Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark,” which I guess...

Language