LOADING ...

NFL Hall Of Famers Are Already Backing Away From The Letter Demanding Better Retirement Benefits

Chris Thompson Sep 19, 2018. 10 comments

The names of 21 NFL greats are listed at the bottom of the letter announced today demanding health insurance and pensions for Hall of Famers . By definition it’s an impressive list, but it’s getting less impressive by the hour: both Kurt Warner and Jerry Rice have now publicly disavowed the letter’s specific demands and threats:

Eric Dickerson, listed as “Chairman, Hall of Fame Board” on the letter, went on Outside The Lines Tuesday to explain his group’s thinking, and to address the perception that his board’s efforts start and stop at looking out for Hall of Famers:

“I’m trying to help the Hall of Famers. That is my goal. That is our goal. The guys who talked about this, this is our goal is to help the players. And also not just the Hall of Famers. I want to make that perfectly clear. One thing is we have to have a seat at the CBA table. We want all players to have health insurance, not just Hall of Famers.”

Dickerson also told ESPN that he views this step—advocating for health insurance specifically for the legends of the game—as a necessary first step, before they can get to expanding his proposed benefits to all retired players.

“We have to get to 1 before we can get to 10. You have to start with the Hall of Famers because we’re trying to get some power first. We don’t have a voice at the table and we’re trying to get there with the attention of the Hall of Famers first. When you get Hall of Famers talking, hopefully you get the attention of the masses.”

It’s probably not a coincidence that both Rice’s and Warner’s statements make a point of mentioning all retired players, and that Dickerson is having to explain the exclusion of non-Hall of Famers during the first part of the public relations phase of this push. It seems like the plan was to use the fame and stature of Hall of Famers as leverage in order to get representation for retirees in league business. But there also appear to have been two failures, here: the failure to fully brief everyone whose name appears on the letter; and the compounding failure to anticipate how players might feel about being associated with an effort to lift Hall of Famers into a separate bargaining class, pursuing exclusive benefits. It’s created an unanticipated scenario where players come out looking more heroic for disavowing the effort than they do by sticking with it.

10 Comments

Other Chris Thompson's posts

Bryce Harper's Walk-Off Grand Slam Was Pure Catharsis Bryce Harper's Walk-Off Grand Slam Was Pure Catharsis

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFThe Philadelphia Phillies were down to the Chicago Cubs entering the bottom of the ninth inning Thursday night. The Cubs have had a dicey bullpen all season long, so this was by no means a sure thing, but that doesn’t make what happened any less nad-rocking, for all...

Jon Gruden Turns Worrying Shade Of Red Over Preseason Delay-Of-Game Penalty Jon Gruden Turns Worrying Shade Of Red Over Preseason Delay-Of-Game Penalty

Mike Glennon threw a 53-yard touchdown pass to [checks notes] Rico Gafford in the first quarter of Thursday night’s Raiders-Cardinals preseason game on ESPN. Immediately afterward, with the poor, addled fans in attendance still buzzing over the hookup, Oakland’s field goal unit took a delay of game penalty while lined up for the extra point. Raiders head coach Jon...

Nick Kyrgios Uses Bathroom Break To Demolish Two Rackets, Then Spits At Umpire In Latest Meltdown Nick Kyrgios Uses Bathroom Break To Demolish Two Rackets, Then Spits At Umpire In Latest Meltdown

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFNick Kyrgios melted down spectacularly Wednesday night at the Cincinnati Masters, in a second-round loss to eighth seed Karen Khachanov, 6–7, 7–6, 6–2. Kyrgios completed a stirring comeback in the first set but started coming unglued in the second set, after chair umpire Fergus Murphy hit him with...

Former MMA Guy Gives Alarmingly Cagey Interview About Working For Jeffrey Epstein Former MMA Guy Gives Alarmingly Cagey Interview About Working For Jeffrey Epstein

Igor Zinoviev’s mixed martial arts career ended unceremoniously in 1998 when he was wiped out in 22 seconds by Frank Shamrock at UFC 16. That brief seven-match career in sanctioned MMA ultimately will not go down as Zinoviev’s claim to fame—the Russian strongman spent years in the employ of recently deceased world-class dirtbag Jeffrey Epstein, serving as driver, bodyguard,...

Suggested posts

Ezekiel Elliott Won't Face Criminal Charges For Knocking Over Event Staffer In Vegas Ezekiel Elliott Won't Face Criminal Charges For Knocking Over Event Staffer In Vegas

Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott will not face criminal charges in connection to an incident in May where he shoved a member of an EDM festival’s event staff in Vegas, according to TMZ. Ezekiel Elliott Knocks Over Event Staffer At EDM Festival, Gets Handcuffed Dallas Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott got into a little scuffle with event personnel at...

Avery Williamson's ACL Tear Could Not Have Happened At A Worse Time Avery Williamson's ACL Tear Could Not Have Happened At A Worse Time

NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport reported on Friday that Jets linebacker Avery Williamson had suffered a torn ACL during the team’s preseason game against the Falcons on Thursday. The injury happened with 3:52 left in the second quarter, at which point every defensive starter except for Williamson had been subbed out of the game. On a pass to Atlanta running...

Making Pass Interference Reviewable Isn't Going To Make It Any Clearer Making Pass Interference Reviewable Isn't Going To Make It Any Clearer

Your browser does not support HTML5 video tag.Click here to view original GIFThe play above was flagged. If you didn’t watch—and, dear reader, I sincerely hope you had something better to do last night than watch a Bengals-Skins preseason game into the fourth quarter—can you guess what the call was? Can you guess which player was flagged? More to the...

Coach Who Made $850,000 Last Year Says His Unpaid Players Are Required To Donate $50 To Program Coach Who Made $850,000 Last Year Says His Unpaid Players Are Required To Donate $50 To Program

At a post-workout press conference earlier this week, Louisiana-Lafayette Ragin’ Cajuns coach Billy Napier announced a rather odd initiative for the members of his football team. Napier said that, starting this year, all scholarship members of the team will be required to donate a minimum of $50 to the Ragin’ Cajun Athletic Foundation. That seems like a punitive rule...

Aaron Rodgers Is Worried About Lamar Jackson's Safety, Too Aaron Rodgers Is Worried About Lamar Jackson's Safety, Too

It’s hard to get enough of Lamar Jackson’s highlight-reel runs, but during Thursday night’s preseason game against the Packers, every muscle on my body tightened up when the young Ravens QB took off to the end zone for a 20-yard run featuring multiple busted tackles. It got called back for a flag, so it didn’t matter even in an...

Kyler Murray's Snap Clap Might Be A Problem Kyler Murray's Snap Clap Might Be A Problem

Kyler Murray played four series in the Cardinals’ loss to the Raiders on Thursday, going 3-for-8 for 12 yards. Not great. But also who cares, it’s preseason. Potentially much more relevant were the two false start penalties he was called for in the first quarter.With just eight called all of last season, false start penalties on quarterbacks are exceedingly...

Jon Gruden Turns Worrying Shade Of Red Over Preseason Delay-Of-Game Penalty Jon Gruden Turns Worrying Shade Of Red Over Preseason Delay-Of-Game Penalty

Mike Glennon threw a 53-yard touchdown pass to [checks notes] Rico Gafford in the first quarter of Thursday night’s Raiders-Cardinals preseason game on ESPN. Immediately afterward, with the poor, addled fans in attendance still buzzing over the hookup, Oakland’s field goal unit took a delay of game penalty while lined up for the extra point. Raiders head coach Jon...

There Is No Ethical Dissent Under Capitalism There Is No Ethical Dissent Under Capitalism

It’s safe to say Jay-Z, to some extent, takes cues from Colin Kaepernick. Jay-Z has expressed his admiration of the former quarterback before, once calling him an “iconic figure.” In the aftermath of Kaepernick’s black-balling from the NFL for his peaceful protest of police killing unarmed black men, Jay-Z rejected the league’s offer to have him perform at the...

Kyle Long Tried To Beat A Teammate With His Own Helmet And Then Barfed Kyle Long Tried To Beat A Teammate With His Own Helmet And Then Barfed

Training camp fights are a relatively common occurrence, but few are as eventful as the scrap that took place on Wednesday between Bears offensive lineman Kyle Long and defensive lineman Jalen Dalton. Here is a description of the fight that is just packed with evocative imagery: Long seems to be having a rough go of it lately. He also...

Jim Harbaugh And Luke Fickell Bicker About The James Hudson Transfer Saga Jim Harbaugh And Luke Fickell Bicker About The James Hudson Transfer Saga

Of all the NCAA’s heavy-handed mechanisms of controlling players, the transfer portal is among the most confusing. The 2018 opening of the portal theoretically makes it easier for athletes to switch schools, though it has done little to actually make things smoother for transferring players, which makes sense since it’s an incremental reform from the fundamentally broken organization. Take...

Language