LOADING ...

This Smart Soundbar Is an Ugly Attempt at an Interesting Idea

Adam Clark Estes Aug 16, 2018. 2 comments

Smart soundbars are an interesting idea. They’re like smart speakers, except they work with your TV, so you can use your voice like a remote control. Neat! In January, Polk wowed CES attendees with its new Command Bar. Put bluntly, this smart device is a big honking soundbar with an Amazon Echo Dot stuffed inside of it. That means the Command Bar can do anything an Echo Dot can do as well as a few extra tricks. It’s pretty ugly, too.

Polk is a well known and much celebrated audio brand with a history of making pricey floor-standing speakers for audiophiles’ living rooms. The Command Bar, however, is a departure of sorts for the decades’ old company. While Polk has long sold soundbars for $500 or more, the new system costs just $300 and comes with Alexa smarts built right in.

That’s an interesting price point for a next-gen gadget that you may or may not find useful. You can buy a regular Echo for $100, but if you’re also in the market for a soundbar, you can spend three times as much money to get the Polk Command Bar, which actually has good audio quality. It even comes with a subwoofer! But the key feature is that the Polk Command Bar comes with an HDMI Arc port—as well as an optical audio port and a USB port designed to accommodate a Fire TV stick—so it will work well with most TVs.

The problem, as mentioned above, is that the Command Bar is a bit of an eyesore. The subwoofer looks like some alien’s trash can, and the soundbar itself kind of resembles a bloated black bō that choked on an Echo Dot. Everything is curvy in the worst of ways, though I realize some people might like the regression to early Aughts design. What really bugs me is the damn light ring on the Echo Dot. It’s just not subtle. If you want to ask Alexa to raise the volume on your TV the light ring will get just as bright and blue as it does on any Alexa, which is a little bit distracting when you’re trying to watch a movie. What’s much worse, however, is the fact that the light ring will glow red at all times when you mute the Echo microphone. That’s much more distracting, if you’re the type of person who would rather not have microphones listening to you all the time. Then again, if you don’t like the idea of easy voice controls, you might not want a smart soundbar to begin with.

Now about those Alexa skills. The Polk Command Bar doesn’t really have any special ones. Volume control is cool, but it only works on certain LG, Samsung, Sony, and Vizio TVs. (Update: While the company lists these as compatible brands on its website, a Polk representative informed me that the Command Bar “is compatible with most TV brands that support ARC/CEC.”) The Command Bar also fails to offer the special TV-specific skills that you’ll find on the new Amazon Fire TV Cube which, despite its faults , does let you use your voice as a remote control. You can do regular Alexa smart home stuff, like turn on your Philips Hue lights or whatever. But you can also do those things with a $30 Echo Dot that’s not hideously crammed into a pricier soundbar.

The Command Bar’s saving grace is that it actually sounds pretty damn good. The soundbar’s huge size makes for a big sound stage, and ugly as it may be, the subwoofer provides strong, balanced bass. That makes watching a war movie like Platoon much more engrossing with the Command Bar than with, say, the cheaper $200 Samsung TV Mate , and the simple fact that the Polk soundbar comes with a subwoofer almost makes it seem like a better deal than the new $400 Sonos Beam, another new smart soundbar with Alexa skills . Though it’s worth pointing out that the Sonos Beam also support’s Apple AirPlay 2 and is supposed to get Google Assistant support later this year.

If you’re choosing between those three soundbars, all of which are new this year, you will be paying for what you get. Which is why Polk’s Command Bar is at least worth considering. You can spend more money and get a more attractive, more feature-filled soundbar like the Sonos Beam which lacks a subwoofer. You can spend less and get the kind of crappy but still functional Samsung TV Mate and probably feel disappointed with your decision. Or you can get the ugly Command Bar. You might not even think it’s ugly, if you’re a fan of clunky, backwards-looking Amazon design.

There’s a chance that the Command Bar will get more useful. Alexa is always adding more skills, as they say. But for me, personally, I wouldn’t want this thing in my living room no matter how smart it got.

README

  • Good soundbar
  • Bad Alexa integration
  • Bad design
  • Good price (okay, pretty good)

2 Comments

Other Adam Clark Estes's posts

Actually, the Small iPhone Is Bad Actually, the Small iPhone Is Bad

A new analyst report says that Apple will release a second-generation iPhone SE at the beginning of next year. Lovers of the old Apple design with its 4-inch screen will be tempted to rejoice and welcome back the iPhone for people with small hands, but that would be premature. According to almost every rumor, the new iPhone SE will...

The New Cheap iPad Is Better Than Ever The New Cheap iPad Is Better Than Ever

If you want to buy a brand new iPad for not much money, the choice is obvious: get the new 10.2-inch, seventh-generation iPad. It’s a great value! Unfortunately, however, Apple is not in the bargain business. Although this iPad is now closer in size to the 11-inch iPad Pro, the significant gulf in the quality of its components is...

All the Ways That Amazon Is Fixing Alexa All the Ways That Amazon Is Fixing Alexa

Amazon announced a bunch of new stuff at a big event in Seattle today. Chief among them are a volley of new features and improved functionalities for Alexa. Some of them are pretty neat. One of them involves Samuel L. Jackson.Alexa is a little more private Amazon addressed privacy concerns with Alexa and Echo devices right out of the...

Stop What You're Doing and Upgrade to iOS 13.1 Right Now Stop What You're Doing and Upgrade to iOS 13.1 Right Now

Apple just dropped iOS 13.1, and while these iterative versions tend not to be as fun as the big numbered ones, you should update your phone right now.iOS 13, Apple said, would be a lot of fun . There’s dark mode, some map stuff, a few new privacy protections. But what Apple didn’t tell you was that iOS 13...

Suggested posts

10 Tips and Tricks to Make You a Sonos Master 10 Tips and Tricks to Make You a Sonos Master

Sonos speakers have been providing high-fidelity wireless audio streaming hardware for several years now, but in recent times its tech has been evolving fast: We’ve seen portable versions of its speakers, the addition of on-board digital assistants, new support for audio protocols, and more besides. Here are ten tips to help you get the most out of your Sonos...

OnePlus Is a TV Company Now OnePlus Is a TV Company Now

While it started off as a smartphone maker, OnePlus has since moved into other categories including wireless headphones, car chargers, and even backpacks. But now, OnePlus is making a major push into a brand new segment with its first TV. Simply called the OnePlus TV Q1, OnePlus is hoping to put the expertise it’s acquired making smartphones to use...

Leaker Claims Alexa-Powered Earbuds Are Amazon's Next Big Device Leaker Claims Alexa-Powered Earbuds Are Amazon's Next Big Device

Amazon has a product launch scheduled for later this week on Wednesday, and alongside a bunch of updated Echo speakers, recent leaks claim Amazon’s next big tech push could come in the form of Alexa-powered wireless earbuds. Based on info from a source who spoke to CNBC, the rumored earbuds are codenamed “Puget” and are designed to make Amazon’s...

TiVo Reportedly Rolling Out Pre-Roll Ads That Play Before Users Can Watch Recorded Video TiVo Reportedly Rolling Out Pre-Roll Ads That Play Before Users Can Watch Recorded Video

TiVo is introducing skippable pre-roll ads before customers can watch shows taped on their retail DVRs, Light Reading reported, with a spokesperson telling the site it will be a “permanent part of the service.”According to Light Reading, the spokesperson added that the company expects the tech “to be fully rolled-out to all eligible retail devices within 90 days.” However,...

The New Bluetooth Sonos Feels Like a Time Warp The New Bluetooth Sonos Feels Like a Time Warp

You don’t need the new Sonos Move. It’s a $400 Sonos speaker that sounds an awful lot like a $180 Sonos speaker but with the added benefit of being portable. You can pick it up and carry it around. If you wander away from your wifi, no problem! The Move is the first Sonos that can stream music over...

Leaked Slide Shows Google to Add Stadia Support, Launch 'Hero Device' for Android TV in 2020 Leaked Slide Shows Google to Add Stadia Support, Launch 'Hero Device' for Android TV in 2020

Google is planning on rolling out a bevy of new features for its Android TV platform in the coming years, including its much-awaited Stadia game streaming service, according to a leak on XDA Developers.According to XDA Developers, an attendee at the International Broadcasting Convention, where Google often “attends the event to unveil the latest updates for the Android TV...

Comcast, Cable Giants Sue Maine Over Law Forcing Them to Let Customers Pay for Specific Channels Comcast, Cable Giants Sue Maine Over Law Forcing Them to Let Customers Pay for Specific Channels

Comcast and a bevy of cable giants including Fox, CBS, and Disney are suing the state of Maine and 17 municipalities over a recently passed state law that mandates cable TV operators allow subscribers to pick and choose which channels and programs they want to pay for, the Bangor Daily News reported this week.The law in question mandates that...

Healing Crystals, Hurricane Dorian, and a $14,000 Gamer Chair: Best Gizmodo Stories of the Week Healing Crystals, Hurricane Dorian, and a $14,000 Gamer Chair: Best Gizmodo Stories of the Week

The first week of September 2019 is over, folks, and we came back from Labor Day cool, relaxed, and ready for news—and boy did we get it.Over the past few days, we’ve hit everything from an exclusive look at a letter former Uber CEO Travis Kalanick wrote admitting his failures , a major Wikileaks source being called to testify...

TCL's New Soundbar Uses Acoustic Tricks to Bring You Cheap Dolby Atmos TCL's New Soundbar Uses Acoustic Tricks to Bring You Cheap Dolby Atmos

There’s a common problem with soundbars. They only sound as big as they are, and soundbars, by design, are compact systems. TCL wants to solve this problem with a new acoustic solution that can blast sound all around your living room thanks to some slick curves and Dolby Atmos technology. It’s a wacky idea, and it in my brief...

The Expensive New Sonos Bluetooth Speaker Baffles Me in Many Ways The Expensive New Sonos Bluetooth Speaker Baffles Me in Many Ways

Sonos is expanding its horizons with a rugged new portable outdoor speaker. It’s called the Sonos Move, and it costs $400. Also, as its portability might suggest, the new device will be the first Sonos speaker that can stream music over a Bluetooth connection. As I held the thing from its gracefully designed handle at a recent Sonos press...

Language