LOADING ...

Grey’s Anatomy’s lengthy existence isn’t a joke, it’s a strength

Caroline Siede May 22, 2018. 24 comments

In a recent episode of Grey’s Anatomy titled “Cold As Ice” (the penultimate episode of the show’s 14th season and its 316th episode overall) one of the doctors arrives in the ER hypothermic and seemingly dead. “We’re not gonna lose her,” announces Meredith Grey (Ellen Pompeo). “The same thing happened to me and I was in way worse shape.” In fact, we saw that happen 11 years ago in the iconic third season episode “Drowning On Dry Land.” In place of made-up character backstory, Grey’s has well over a decade of “history” to draw from—history its audience has seen unfold in real-time. And while the show’s lengthy existence is sometimes treated as a punchline, Grey’s Anatomy has found huge emotional power in calling back to its past.

In an excellent piece about the way Crazy Ex-Girlfriend uses musical reprises, Allison Shoemaker writes, “A reprise is no longer just a reprise. A reprise is now, with apologies to Don Draper, a time machine. They’re songs that send us back through the personal history of Rebecca Bunch, encouraging us to consider personal growth (or lack thereof), the evolution of relationships, and the significance of her own memories.” That’s essentially what Grey’s Anatomy does in non-song form. (And sometimes even in song form too. The show’s seventh season musical episode featured covers of pop songs the show helped made famous and in last night’s season finale, the show played one of those covers to emotionally link us to a character who left at the end of season 12.) In regularly and casually calling back to events from throughout its run, Grey’s Anatomy isn’t just linking us to its characters’ past, it’s linking long-time viewers to their own pasts, too.

For instance, I was in high school when I watched Meredith briefly visit purgatory while struggling through her own hypothermia. I was in my freshman year college dorm room when I watched Owen Hunt (Kevin McKidd) help Cristina Yang (Sandra Oh) with an icicle injury. I was in my very first apartment when I watched a deadly plane crash take out a bunch of the show’s major players. And it was a couple years later that I began reviewing the series for The A.V. Club, starting with an episode that moved backwards in time through the relationship history of two of its long-running characters. The show’s references don’t just send me back through the characters’ personal history, they send me back through my own as well—the places I used to live, the friends I used to watch with, and the people I used to be at various points in my life.

A long-running show like Grey’s Anatomy measures its successes and failures in eras, not episodes or even seasons. And while Grey’s Anatomy has had some real low points over the years (yes, this is a medical series where someone had sex with a ghost that turned out to be a manifestation of her brain tumor), it’s had plenty of peaks to counter those valleys. The show’s most recent creative renaissance came thanks to its biggest ever creative shakeup—the decision to kill off Patrick Dempsey’s Dr. Derek “McDreamy” Shepherd in the 11th season episode “How To Save A Life.” In examining what Meredith’s life looks like in a post-Derek world, Grey’s Anatomy got a creative kick start (not to mention a ratings boost). And since then it’s been refreshingly willing to mine its own past for emotional resonance, most successfully in seasons 12 and 14.

Though ER still has Grey’s beat by a season in terms of longest-running medical dramas (at least for now), Grey’s has had a more consistent cast over the years. Four of the current Grey’s Anatomy stars have been with the show from the very beginning—Pompeo’s Meredith Grey, Justin Chambers’ Alex Karev, Chandra Wilson’s Miranda Bailey, and James Pickens Jr.’s Richard Webber—and they’ve become emotional anchors for the series. And while some long-running series prefer not to acknowledge the creative shakeups they’ve had over the years, Grey’s has never been shy about discussing its departed characters. To celebrate its 300th episode, the show warmly reflected back on pretty much all the major characters who were once central to the series. In other words, Grey’s lets its characters talk about the people from their pasts in the way that real-life people do, not the way that characters in a TV show seem to so often forget about friends sent off to “Mandyville.”

The show’s best callbacks are an emotional gut punch, like a sudden and unexpected flashback to Derek in the 12th season episode “My Next Life,” which also featured the return of Meredith’s first ever patient from the Grey’s Anatomy pilot (played on both occasions by Skyler Shaye). It’s a tiny five-second moment, more of a flash than a flashback, but it carries a huge emotional resonance for those who have stuck with the series over the years. Thanks to its long history, Grey’s Anatomy has developed the ability to replicate what memory feels like—a sudden thought that comes and goes but still carries enormous weight.

From the beginning, one of Grey’s biggest strengths has been its willingness to let its characters and their relationships with one another genuinely evolve, which is how the Meredith/Alex friendship emerged as the unexpected heart of the series in its current era. There’s procedural element to the series, but it’s first and foremost a character drama. And while the show sometimes gets silly with its self-referential callbacks (there’s a certain amount of dark comedy in just how much trauma and death these doctors have experienced over the years), it also uses them to reflect on those evolutions. When “syph nurse” Olivia Harper (Sarah Utterback) returned this season for a one-episode guest spot after an eight-season absence, she served as a reminder of just how far Alex has come since his early days as an irresponsible bad boy.

For the most part, Grey’s doesn’t do much handholding when it comes to these references. It knows it has a large and devoted fan base who will pick up on small gestures and lines, like a moment in the 14th season finale where Meredith tells Alex, “She’s not the sun, you are the sun”—a reference to the speech Cristina delivered before leaving Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. “Cold As Ice” ends with Meredith folding a scrub cap covered in ferryboat illustrations and placing it in a drawer next to a framed Post-It note. There’s no overt explanation as to exactly what she’s doing, but longtime viewers know the scrub cap was one of Derek’s favorites, the Post-It note was their unofficial marriage license, and the whole gesture is a huge step in Meredith’s process of moving on to a new chapter in her post-Derek life.

The current trend toward TV shows having shorter runs with fewer episodes per season is probably a good thing. It allows writers to focus on quality over quantity and attracts high-profile actors who don’t feel locked down by the production schedules. But Grey’s Anatomy stands as a testament to the power of an old-fashioned, long-running network series, too. According to Pompeo, Grey’s will likely be ending its impressive run sooner rather than later. (Creator Shonda Rhimes has always maintained that she’ll keep the show running for as long as Pompeo wants to be a part of it and Pompeo recently signed an impressive deal that includes two more seasons.) Until then, however, I’m happy to pick, choose, and love Grey’s Anatomy and the moving way it utilizes its own history.

24 Comments

Other Caroline Siede's posts

A nostalgic Supergirl is a Winn-Winn A nostalgic Supergirl is a Winn-Winn

TV Reviews All of our TV reviews in one convenient place.Prev NextView All Supergirl isn’t a show I watch for plot, which is good because “Back From The Future—Part One” doesn’t really have one. Okay, technically there are events that bring our heroes together and a desperate rush to save the future to ostensibly give the whole thing stakes. But,...

Whoa, tonight’s Doctor Who is a game-changer Whoa, tonight’s Doctor Who is a game-changer

TV Reviews All of our TV reviews in one convenient place.Prev NextView All Premieres, finales, and specials. Those are the places where Doctor Who usually delivers massive reveals about its own mythos. So while I was ready for this mid-season episode to provide an opportunity to wax nostalgic about the return of a Russell T. Davies-era alien, I certainly...

This Is Us turns Randall’s anxiety into a horror movie This Is Us turns Randall’s anxiety into a horror movie

TV Reviews All of our TV reviews in one convenient place.Prev NextView All After last week’s terrifying cliffhanger, it’s a relief that “A Hell Of A Week: Part One” isn’t an hour-long home invasion thriller in which Randall has to fight to save his family. Instead, the break-in is resolved in the opening few minutes, as Randall gives the...

A post-Crisis Supergirl resets its universe A post-Crisis Supergirl resets its universe

TV Reviews All of our TV reviews in one convenient place.Prev NextView All In the past, the Arrowverse’s big crossover events were self-contained enough that you could pretty much skip them and still follow along with Supergirl’s storytelling just fine. That’s very much not the case for Crisis On Infinite Earths, an event that rewrote the fundamental worldbuilding of...

Suggested posts

Twelve seasons later, Grey’s Anatomy brings back its very first patient Twelve seasons later, Grey’s Anatomy brings back its very first patient

TV ReviewsAll of our TV reviews in one convenient place.  Grey's AnatomySeason 12Grey's AnatomySeason 12"My Next Life"BGrey's AnatomySeason 12"My Next Life"BB"My Next Life"Episode12I wrote last week about Grey’s Anatomy’s unique ability to pull from 12 seasons of history when it wants to confront its characters with the past. And that’s on display tonight as Meredith’s first ever patient returns to...

Meredith answers a question on this week’s Grey’s Anatomy Meredith answers a question on this week’s Grey’s Anatomy

TV ReviewsAll of our TV reviews in one convenient place.  Grey's AnatomySeason 12Grey's AnatomySeason 12"I Am Not Waiting Anymore"BGrey's AnatomySeason 12"I Am Not Waiting Anymore"BB"I Am Not Waiting Anymore"Episode15“I Am Not Waiting Anymore” isn’t a particularly great episode of Grey’s Anatomy. Neither of the cases were all that compelling, I don’t care nearly as much about Meredith’s love life as...

Wilmer Valderrama says good day to Grey’s Anatomy Wilmer Valderrama says good day to Grey’s Anatomy

TV ReviewsAll of our TV reviews in one convenient place.  Grey's AnatomySeason 12Grey's AnatomySeason 12"I Wear The Face"B-Grey's AnatomySeason 12"I Wear The Face"B-B-"I Wear The Face"Episode17Any show churning out over 22 episodes a season is going to wind up with some filler. After the inventive storytelling of “The Sound Of Silence” and “Unbreak My Heart,” Grey’s has been spinning its...

A two-episode “event” highlights Grey’s Anatomy at its best and worst A two-episode “event” highlights Grey’s Anatomy at its best and worst

TV ReviewsAll of our TV reviews in one convenient place.  Grey's AnatomySeason 12Grey's AnatomySeason 12"It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding)" / "There's A Fine, Fine Line"Grey's AnatomySeason 12"It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding)" / "There's A Fine, Fine Line""It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding)" / "There's A Fine, Fine Line"Title"It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding)"ScoreCEpisode19Title"There's A Fine, Fine Line"ScoreAEpisode18Tonight’s double-header...

The 100th episode of Scandal poses a tantalizing “what if?” The 100th episode of Scandal poses a tantalizing “what if?”

Here’s what’s up in the world of TV for Thursday, April 13. All times are Eastern.Top pickScandal (ABC, 9 p.m.): A show as twisty and twisted as Scandal shouldn’t celebrate a TV milestone in a traditional manner. Instead, Shonda Rhimes’ political thriller marks the occasion by returning to Olivia, Mellie, and Cyrus’ decision to rig the presidential election in...

Alex bids Grey’s a possible and poignant goodbye Alex bids Grey’s a possible and poignant goodbye

TV ReviewsAll of our TV reviews in one convenient place.  Grey's AnatomySeason 13Grey's AnatomySeason 13"You Haven't Done Nothin'"BGrey's AnatomySeason 13"You Haven't Done Nothin'"BB"You Haven't Done Nothin'"Episode9One reason why Grey’s Anatomy is still on the air in its 13th season is due to over-the-top allegories like this one. A building, i.e. the world, collapses, and the survivors and relatives of the...

A Grey’s Anatomy wedding leads a night of finales A Grey’s Anatomy wedding leads a night of finales

Here’s what’s up in the world of TV for Thursday, May 19. All times are Eastern. Top picksGrey’s Anatomy (ABC, 8 p.m.): Against all odds, Grey’s Anatomy somehow managed a creative renaissance in its 12th season. The death of Derek “McDreamy” Shepherd last year revitalized the show and even inspired The A.V. Club to start regular coverage for the...

Grey’s is the new black Grey’s is the new black

TV ReviewsAll of our TV reviews in one convenient place.  Grey's AnatomySeason 13Grey's AnatomySeason 13"You Can Look (But You Better Not Touch)"Grey's AnatomySeason 13"You Can Look (But You Better Not Touch)""You Can Look (But You Better Not Touch)"Episode10Because The A.V. Club knows that TV shows keep going even if we’re not writing at length about them, we’re experimenting with discussion...

Riverdale: The Re-Skeeting Riverdale: The Re-Skeeting

Here’s what’s up in the world of TV for Thursday, March 9. All times are Eastern.Top pickRiverdale (The CW, 8 p.m.): As part of its cheeky ode to movie and TV teens of the past, The CW’s Archie adaptation loves casting yesterday’s heartthrobs and girls next door as today’s moms and dads. Fred Andrews looks a lot less link...

There’s nothing better than the Better Things season finale There’s nothing better than the Better Things season finale

Here’s what’s up in the world of TV for Thursday, November 10. All times are Eastern. Top picksGrey’s Anatomy (ABC, 8 p.m.): While we aren’t covering Grey’s Anatomy in-depth this season, Gwen Ihnat has been keeping up with the show in weekly discussion posts. But even if she weren’t, we’re pretty sure we’d be contractually obligated as pop-culture lovers...

Language