LOADING ...

House Passes 'Online Sex Trafficking' Bill That Critics Say Actually Silences Survivors

Julianne Escobedo Shepherd Mar 01, 2018. 18 comments

A bipartisan coalition of U.S. representatives has voted to pass the Allow States and Victims to Fight Online Sex Trafficking Act (FOSTA), as well as an amendment introduced by Rep. Mimi Walters (R-CA) aimed at holding websites like Backpage.com accountable if third parties use them to traffic sex. The problem, say sex worker advocates, is that the bill not only does nothing to actually help sex trafficking victims—it makes sex work a federal crime in the process.

FOSTA follows the contours of the Stop Enabling Sex Traffickers Act (SESTA), passed by the Senate in November, which would make it illegal for Backpage and similar websites to “knowingly assist, facilitate, or support sex trafficking.” Criticism of FOSTA and SESTA has focused on how both bills weaken internet freedoms; after SESTA’s passage, the Electronic Freedom Foundation wrote about the way enforcement is as likely to silence trafficking victims as traffickers due to the limitations of technology:

Some SESTA supporters imagine that compliance with SESTA would be easy—that online platforms would simply need to use automated filters to pinpoint and remove all messages in support of sex trafficking and leave everything else untouched. But such filters do not and cannot exist: computers aren’t good at recognizing subtlety and context, and with severe penalties at stake, no rational company would trust them to.

Online platforms would have no choice but to program their filters to err on the side of removal, silencing a lot of innocent voices in the process. And remember, the first people silenced are likely to be trafficking victims themselves: it would be a huge technical challenge to build a filter that removes sex trafficking advertisements but doesn’t also censor a victim of trafficking telling her story or trying to find help.

This week the EFF reiterated this position on FOSTA, but also emphasized its piecemealness, calling it “a Frankenstein bill” that “would be a disaster for Internet intermediaries, marginalized communities, and even trafficking victims themselves.” And beyond being flawed, it also specifically collapses the very important delineation between trafficking and sex work, further criminalizing the latter while endangering sex workers. From ThinkProgress:

Kate D’Adamo, a partner with Reframe Health and Justice, a consulting collective focused on economic justice and public health, said sex workers often use online platforms for harm reduction.

“When I was an organizer, we had a listserv where we sent out information about violent clients so people could screen for violence,” she said. “That doesn’t exist if you curtailed anything related to the facilitation of prostitution. Any harm reduction and screening posted online would be subjected to a federal crime punishable by 10 years.”

D’Adamo explained that when sex workers can go online to find clients, they are less vulnerable to violence than if they did so on the street. When sex workers are more worried about law enforcement attention, they seek out more isolated areas to work and as a result, they experience more violence.

FOSTA passed overwhelmingly in the house, with just 25 nays—14 Republican, 11 Democrat. It is now headed to the Senate.

18 Comments

Other Julianne Escobedo Shepherd's posts

Goodbye to Anna Merlan, Finally Skulking Into the Night Where She Belongs Goodbye to Anna Merlan, Finally Skulking Into the Night Where She Belongs

After five years at Jezebel, Special Projects, and Jezebel, our most beloved conspiracy theory-deflater and receiver of terrible emails Anna Merlan leaves us today. You know what that means: It’s time for a motherfucking roast.Emma Carmichael, Unemployed Writer in Los Angeles/Former Editor-in-Chief, JezebelIt was a major coup to hire Anna away from Witches Quarterly back in 2014, and I...

All the Fine Glam and Freaky Fashion on the 71st Emmy Awards Show Red Carpet All the Fine Glam and Freaky Fashion on the 71st Emmy Awards Show Red Carpet

A tipster who may or may not be up for an Emmy this year alerted Jezebel that this week, some rented dresses may have not shown up on time for the big event. If this is true, I welcome it: As I note in virtually every awards-show fashion post, red carpet looks have narrowed to the point of being...

Climate Activism Is Feminism In a Dying World Climate Activism Is Feminism In a Dying World

In the absence of clear, concise, and unified action from elected officials around the world to fight the climate crisis, it’s the utmost bullshit that teenagers, children, and other students have had to step in and rise up. The nihilism driving this lack of interest (or, in cases like the Trump administration, abject mendacity) goes beyond simple financial greed and...

You Can Never Have Too Many Hangers You Can Never Have Too Many Hangers

New York Fashion Week has commenced its perpetual cyclone of DOING THINGS and LOOKING AT PEOPLE; despite rumors of its decline in recent years, it is something like a fixed game, where influencers and brands will always be peacocking no matter what form it takes, or where it happens. And sure as Fashion Week exists, there will always be...

Suggested posts

Prince Andrew Might Want to Come Up With a Better Excuse Prince Andrew Might Want to Come Up With a Better Excuse

Prince Andrew, Duke of York has an explanation for why he was spotted on camera hanging out at Jeffrey Epstein’s Manhattan sex-trafficking mansion in 2010. What is it, you ask? Why, he was there to friend-dump Epstein, of course. Nothing to see here! Move along!“The duke has been hammered for one mistake, which took place in 2010,” a “source”...

Jeffrey Epstein Was Seen With Underage Girls in 2018, Another Investigation Reveals Jeffrey Epstein Was Seen With Underage Girls in 2018, Another Investigation Reveals

An air traffic controller reported seeing Jeffrey Epstein get off his private plane in 2018 with girls who looked to be 11 and 12 years old, a new cache of documents released by the U.S. Marshals Service has revealed.Though it was the Manhattan U.S. Attorney that ultimately charged Epstein with sex trafficking in July, the Marshals Service had been...

Dancers Say Jeffrey Epstein Would Recruit Them From NYC Studios to Give Him 'Erotic Massages' Dancers Say Jeffrey Epstein Would Recruit Them From NYC Studios to Give Him 'Erotic Massages'

Jeffrey Epstein used Manhattan dance studios to recruit young women to give him “erotic massages,” according to a report in the New York Times.The Times says several lawsuits have been filed against Epstein’s estate alleging the convicted sex offender included young dancers among the many, many young women and underage girls he exploited, abused, trafficked, and otherwise victimized. According to...

Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly Relied on a 'Ring' of Women to Recruit Victims Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly Relied on a 'Ring' of Women to Recruit Victims

On the heels of Epstein survivors urging authorities to continue investigating those who aided him in alleged sex trafficking and the sexual assaults of dozens of women and girls, four women who were named “possible co-conspirators” and granted immunity in Florida a decade ago could now face criminal charges in Manhattan.According to the New York Times, Sarah Kellen, Lesley...

Jeffrey Epstein’s New Will Sets Up Another Roadblock For Victims Seeking Justice Jeffrey Epstein’s New Will Sets Up Another Roadblock For Victims Seeking Justice

According to AP, Jeffrey Epstein’s will, set up two days prior to his death by suicide earlier this month, included a trust fund worth $577 million in assets made up of $56 million in cash, $18.5 million in vehicles and aircraft, and property around the globe. Estate lawyers believe it will take years to open the trust and divide...

New Accusers Say Epstein Abused Them With Sex Toys, Raped Teen After She Told Him She Was a Virgin New Accusers Say Epstein Abused Them With Sex Toys, Raped Teen After She Told Him She Was a Virgin

Three new accusers have come forward in the wake of Jeffrey Epstein’s suicide to allege the convicted pedophile sexually abused and raped them. Among the deeply disturbing accusations: Epstein abused them with sex toys, forced one woman to marry a “recruiter” so she could stay in the country, and raped one 17-year-old even after she told him she didn’t...

Guards in Charge of Jeffrey Epstein Were Reportedly Working 'Extreme' Overtime Shifts When He Died Guards in Charge of Jeffrey Epstein Were Reportedly Working 'Extreme' Overtime Shifts When He Died

In the wake of Jeffrey Epstein’s apparent suicide this weekend, it’s unclear what will happen to the investigation into a massive global sex trafficking ring that allegedly involved a number of powerful people. Also unclear: whether Epstein’s victims will ever see an iota of justice. But there’s a nagging question of how Epstein managed to die by suicide, while...

Jeffrey Epstein Has Died By Suicide Jeffrey Epstein Has Died By Suicide

Officials at a Manhattan jail report that convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide on the night of August 9.Epstein was arrested on July 6 over the sex trafficking and abuse of dozens of young women and girls, some as young as 14, and being held without bail in a Manhattan jail while facing up to 45 years...

'It Was Biological, Like Eating': Records Reveal The Powerful Men Allegedly Associated With Jeffrey Epstein's Trafficking Ring 'It Was Biological, Like Eating': Records Reveal The Powerful Men Allegedly Associated With Jeffrey Epstein's Trafficking Ring

New documents unsealed by a Manhattan federal appeals court on Friday revealed some disturbing details in the apparently ever-expanding Jeffrey Epstein case, who is accused of sex trafficking of minors .According to the New York Post, the documents are from a defamation lawsuit originally brought by Epstein accuser Virginia Giuffre, née Roberts, against his alleged madame, English socialite Ghislaine...

The Mystery of How Jeffrey Epstein Made His Money The Mystery of How Jeffrey Epstein Made His Money

Since noted sexual predator, convicted sex offender, and (alleged) pedophile Jeffrey Epstein was arrested last weekend, a flurry of articles have come out that describe him as a “billionaire,” a descriptor that we’ve also used here at Jezebel. The financier part is true, but is he in fact a billionaire? The answer seems to be no—and an examination of...

Language