LOADING ...

Paddington 2 has now climbed to the very top of the Rotten Tomatoes peak

William Hughes Jan 21, 2018. 20 comments

Earlier this week, we reported on a somewhat surprising milestone for the recently released kids’ film Paddington 2, when the Paul King-directed crowdpleaser became one of only four current films to claim a 100 percent certified “fresh” rating on review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes. It crossed another, even bigger one today, though, when it scored its 164th (and then 165th) positive reviews, pushing it past the previous record held by Toy Story 2, and making it the most agreed-upon perfect-scored film in the site’s history.

Which raises the obvious question: Why Paddington 2? Our own Ignatiy Vishnevetsky was one of the 165 people praising it, after all—highlighting its bright visuals and appeal to adults as well as kids—but he still only gave its considerable charms a B. If nothing else, it underlines the idea that Rotten Tomatoes is a pretty good barometer for identifying pleasant—maybe even good—films, but less useful as the end-all-be-all metric for Hollywood success that so many industry insiders seem to view it as. (The film’s box-office receipts have been perfectly respectable, but not absolute blockbusters, after all.)

And, of course, this new record might only be temporary. Greta Gerwig’s Lady Bird—which has 50 more positive reviews than good old Paddington—was well on its way to claiming the throne for itself, when a single C+ assessment brought it down to a measly 99 percent fresh. (A.k.a.: Garbage.) The same thing could happen to our fun little bruin, too, even if director Gray seems happy to ride this wave of popular sentiment for as long as he can:

The Paddington films are a real labour of love. So many people pour their hearts and souls into them for months or even years, hand-crafting every last frame, and we are all incredibly grateful for the overwhelmingly positive response we’ve had so far. We hope it inspires people to go to the cinema to see for themselves if a talking animal film really can be any good, and whether Hugh Grant really can look devilishly handsome even while dressed as a nun. (Clue: yes.)

[via SlashFilm]

20 Comments

Other William Hughes's posts

Glenlivet's seaweed pouch Scotch pods are a triumphant testament to the power of stupid Glenlivet's seaweed pouch Scotch pods are a triumphant testament to the power of stupid

Carefully honed stupidity is a powerful marketing commodity—to the point where a company like Taco Bell can forge entire fast food empires out of slapping leftover junkfood dust together in a drawer and then compelling you to dare your buddies to eat it. But while the science of flavor-blasting continues apace is the fast-casual market, it rarely touches on...

Looks like Kamala Khan is going to be a huge part of the Marvel's Avengers game Looks like Kamala Khan is going to be a huge part of the Marvel's Avengers game

We’ve been hearing for several years now about Crystal Dynamic’s Avengers video game, the Tomb Raider studio’s Marvel-backed effort to translate the most popular movie superheroes on the planet into a decently playable action-adventure experience. (For some reasons, this is a consistently difficult prospect to pull off, as the fate of the aborted Avengers movie tie-in made clear a...

Fans looking at the current line of Star Wars merch are wondering: Where's Rose? Fans looking at the current line of Star Wars merch are wondering: Where's Rose?

A few years back, fans of the Star Wars franchise noticed a weird omission in some of the toys and merchandise produced for The Force Awakens: There was precious little stuff with Daisy Ridley’s Rey on it, despite the fact that she is, pretty inarguably, the main character of this new trilogy of films. Thus was the #WheresRey hashtag...

The future is dirty, Spock is annoying, and Picard gives awesome hugs in new set of Star Trek trailers The future is dirty, Spock is annoying, and Picard gives awesome hugs in new set of Star Trek trailers

It’s Star Trek’s time to shine at New York Comic-Con today—even if some of that shininess comes in the form of a pretty dirty future. That’s the major takeaway from the latest teaser for the third season of the franchise’s current flagship show, Discovery, which sees Michael Burnham and pals apparently attempting to reboot the Federation amidst a future...

Suggested posts

I'm Filmmaker Kelsey Taylor, and This Is How I Work I'm Filmmaker Kelsey Taylor, and This Is How I Work

How I WorkHow I WorkThe How I Work series asks heroes, experts, and all-around productive people to share their shortcuts, workspaces, routines, and more.Prev Next View All For the 40th anniversary of the first Alien film, 20th Century Fox (through studio platform Tongal) commissioned six new short films set in the Alien universe. The most popular was Alien: Specimen, directed...

Chicago, see Ethan Hawke’s documentary, Seymour: An Introduction, early and for free Chicago, see Ethan Hawke’s documentary, Seymour: An Introduction, early and for free

In his first documentary, Seymour: An Introduction, Ethan Hawke turns the lens toward Seymour Bernstein, an accomplished pianist who left a concert career to teach. In the doc, the warm and passionate Bernstein shares his story and dispenses wisdom about life and art: He’s basically the opposite of J.K. Simmons’ volatile instructor in Whiplash. Seymour: An Introduction opens in...

Chicago, see Spectre, James Bond’s latest adventure, early and for free Chicago, see Spectre, James Bond’s latest adventure, early and for free

Now that Skyfall has set the bar for Bond sky-high, all eyes are on Spectre, the 24th official entry in the 007 franchise, and the second consecutive film from director Sam Mendes. Whether he likes it, Daniel Craig is back, too, putting his signature brand of wounded steeliness on display in another caper that promises to dig up Bond’s...

R.I.P. Robert Chartoff, Oscar-winning producer of Rocky and Raging Bull R.I.P. Robert Chartoff, Oscar-winning producer of Rocky and Raging Bull

Robert Chartoff, the Oscar-winning producer behind films like Rocky, Raging Bull, and The Right Stuff, died yesterday from pancreatic cancer. He was 81. Chartoff’s introduction to the entertainment business came through his uncle, a talent booker in the Catskills for whom Chartoff worked during summers off from college. After law school, he formed a talent agency with longtime business...

The Last Jedi looks amazing in a new behind-the-scenes footage reel The Last Jedi looks amazing in a new behind-the-scenes footage reel

Given that one aspect of our jobs here at The A.V. Club is to watch pretty much everything that comes out around major film franchises and figure out, “Is this any good?”, it’s pretty easy to get jaded about the bigger ones. That goes especially hard for Star Wars, a cultural juggernaut that’s been riding its own waves of...

The Academy elects Whoopi Goldberg to its Board Of Governors The Academy elects Whoopi Goldberg to its Board Of Governors

The Academy Of Motion Picture Arts And Sciences announced the results of its annual Board Of Governors election today, and it looks like Whoopi Goldberg was one of the big winners. According to Variety, Goldberg scored the currently open Actors Branch spot on the governing board, beating out fellow performers like Geena Davis, Edward James Olmos, and Rita Wilson....

That Ratchet & Clank movie is still happening, and here’s the full trailer That Ratchet & Clank movie is still happening, and here’s the full trailer

It’s never too late to make an adaptation of a relatively popular video game, or at least re-tell a fleshed-out version of the original game. That seems to be the plan for Ratchet & Clank, a feature-film retelling of the first 2002 Playstation 2 game. Whereas the teaser trailer we saw earlier this year offered a brief montage of...

China developing Need For Speed 2 to meet world’s insatiable need for speed China developing Need For Speed 2 to meet world’s insatiable need for speed

The video game adaptation Need For Speed was released last year, in the hope that it could fill the rapacious maw of America’s need for speed in between Fast & Furious movies. A desperate few stumbled shakily to the box office, sweat staining their Dale Earnhardt Jr. jerseys, to get their car movie methadone. But most of the country...

Chazz Palminteri on A Bronx Tale, Keyser Söze, and Stallone’s career advice Chazz Palminteri on A Bronx Tale, Keyser Söze, and Stallone’s career advice

Welcome to Random Roles, wherein we talk to actors about the characters who defined their careers. The catch: They don’t know beforehand what roles we’ll ask them to talk about.The actor: A familiar face to anyone who’s watched a cop or gangster movie from the past 20 years, Chazz Palminteri has established himself as one of Hollywood’s go-to tough...

Dracula is getting another origin story, this time from It's Andy Muschietti Dracula is getting another origin story, this time from It's Andy Muschietti

It’s only been three years since Universal’s Dracula Untold captured the hearts and minds of the world with its dull, uninspired story about a guy named Dracula who isn’t a vampire but later becomes a vampire for some reason, but Paramount has decided that it’s already time for another story about a guy named Dracula becoming a vampire for...

Language