LOADING ...

Shatner Wasn't Initially Too Keen on Khan in Star Trek II

Julie Muncy Aug 21, 2017. 18 comments

Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan was a success on the strength of its villain. But the William Shatner wasn’t sure a returning series villain was such a good idea.

Talking to IGN to promote the 35th anniversary celebration of the film, Shatner shared that he didn’t want to look to the series for inspiration at all for Star Trek II.

He said:

I recall that they began to talk about the second movie, and the talk began to be about what segment of the 79 [TV episodes] that we shot would be useful. And I kept saying, why do we want to go to a segment? Why don’t we invent something absolutely new? And the people in charge were much more aware than I was that the fans would be more sympathetic to… [it] would be a better vibration if it echoed a popular hour from the series, and make that, and then further the story as a film. And they were absolutely right that there was a ramification doing it that way, and the fact that the actor [Ricardo Montalban] was able to repeat his role was another singular advantage.

It’s lucky that Shatner didn’t get his way. Montalban’s performance in that film is timeless, and the conflict between Kirk and Khan is one of the best character beats in all of Trek.

In my opinion, Star Trek isn’t flush with all that many compelling interpersonal conflicts, especially not with regards to villains. There are great characters, absolutely, but plotting often tends to push more conceptual than personal, toward big scifi ideas and away from psychological motivations on the part of the cast. Which isn’t necessarily a criticism! But it’s part of why Khan sings here, and why he’s such a memorable presence in Star Trek II. He offers something we don’t see much in the franchise.

Anyway, we can be glad Shatner got overruled by writer/director Nicholas Meyer and crew. Pity the same couldn’t be said for Star Trek V.

[IGN]

18 Comments

Other Julie Muncy's posts

Jeri Ryan and Sir Patrick Stewart Discuss the Legacy of Star Trek, Spandex, and Being Memes Jeri Ryan and Sir Patrick Stewart Discuss the Legacy of Star Trek, Spandex, and Being Memes

Nerd fame is a strange thing. The sheer passion with which people relate to you, or to something you’ve created, is a lot to handle, even for the most seasoned actor or creator. For the cast of a phenomenon like Star Trek , it must be even more overwhelming. That intensity is part of what makes this interview, conducted...

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina's Showrunner Sheds Some Light on Those Last-Minute Twists Chilling Adventures of Sabrina's Showrunner Sheds Some Light on Those Last-Minute Twists

The third season of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is now available for streaming, and if you devoured it in one big magical gulp you might be a bit perplexed by some of what happened. It’s a twisty mystical world of teen witches and hell legions, and this show’s storytelling has never been straightforward. In particular, the third season ended...

Aspiring King Arthur Rips Disneyland's Excalibur From Its Stone, Breaks It Immediately Aspiring King Arthur Rips Disneyland's Excalibur From Its Stone, Breaks It Immediately

Disneyland’s Excalibur attraction , featuring the famed kingly sword in an anvil, is normally a chance for the park’s visitors to be reminded of The Sword in the Stone. You know, the way-underrated Disney version of the Arthur story, where the chosen one gets to pull the sword out and proceed on his way to the kingdom? Except, you’re...

This Behind-the-Scenes Featurette Explores the Raw, Jovial Energy of Birds of Prey This Behind-the-Scenes Featurette Explores the Raw, Jovial Energy of Birds of Prey

The Harley Quinn-led Birds of Prey looks like so much fun . From the colors to the characters, to the sheer bursting energy that each released bit of footage has had, the whole package seems like a much more interesting space to occupy than most other glimpses of the DC Universe we’ve gotten on film. In a new featurette,...

Suggested posts

Time After Time Is More Timeless Than You Think Time After Time Is More Timeless Than You Think

Released September 28, 1979, sci-fi romance-slash-crime drama Time After Time has a lot of elements that feel quite dated when you watch it today, including some very primitive special effects. But its chilling underlying message still rings true—and its cornier parts make it fun to revisit.In Victorian London, an eccentric gentleman named H.G. Wells (Malcolm McDowell), still a few...

The Beautifully Dull Paradox of Star Trek: The Motion Picture, 40 Years Later The Beautifully Dull Paradox of Star Trek: The Motion Picture, 40 Years Later

Forty years ago a landmark moment in Star Trek’s history arrived, in the form of Star Trek: The Motion Picture. It’s an important chapter in the series’ survival, the turning point from canceled cult classic to enduring icon of science fiction. But there is a reason we remember The Motion Picture’s place in history more than we remember The...

What We Know About Every Star Trek Show in the Works Right Now What We Know About Every Star Trek Show in the Works Right Now

After years and years on the back burner, Star Trek is truly ascendant on television once more. Although for now we just have Star Trek: Discovery, soon enough CBS wants us watching tons of new space exploration shows . While we’re not quite at five hundred twenty-five thousand six hundred Trek shows just yet, there’s a lot—and here’s what...

This Artist Has Turned the Movie Poster Into a Science This Artist Has Turned the Movie Poster Into a Science

If you want to master something, do it a lot. Artist Scott Saslow took that to heart when he, a couple years ago, embarked on a project to create one movie poster a day. Now, he’s still making posters, and his work is incredible—minimal but iconic, made with a deft awareness of exactly how to translate a film into...

Our First Look at What Feels Like the First Star Trek Action Figures in Ages Our First Look at What Feels Like the First Star Trek Action Figures in Ages

There’s plenty of Trek merchandise out there, from giant ship replicas , to fancy dolls , to actual meme statuettes . But for honest to god action figures, it feels like it’s been years since there’s been a line of Starfleet’s finest small enough to command your valuable desk space. That’s finally changing thanks to McFarlane Toys.It’s been about...

William Shatner Boldly Goes Into Promoting Cryptocurrency Mining William Shatner Boldly Goes Into Promoting Cryptocurrency Mining

Steven Seagal and DJ Khaled have taught us that if a celebrity endorses a cryptocurrency project, you should immediately assume it might be a scam. But William Shatner seems to be backing a pretty interesting crypto-mining initiative.The actor who’s best known for playing Captain Kirk and giving odd line-readings didn’t intend to become the latest b-list celebrity to pull a...

William Shatner Responds to Flat Earthers Using His Image to Promote Their Stupid Ideas William Shatner Responds to Flat Earthers Using His Image to Promote Their Stupid Ideas

One-time Star Trek star William Shatner wants you to know that he does not support Flat Earth thinking.The “British Flat Earth Association” today tweeted an image depicting Shatner’s face along with the quote “I was fooled by science, the Earth is flat” and the date April 15, 2017. That came with the text “Great to have the support from...

How Star Trek Is Attempting to Rule Comic-Con 2016 How Star Trek Is Attempting to Rule Comic-Con 2016

We all know 2016 is the 50th anniversary of Star Trek, and that’s cause for a lot of fanfare. A new movie , a new TV show , and multiple conventions are just a few of the things on the way. It also seems Star Trek has set its phasers to conquer the biggest convention of them all: San...

Leonard Nimoy and William Shatner Were on TV Together Years Before Star Trek Leonard Nimoy and William Shatner Were on TV Together Years Before Star Trek

In researching Man from UNCLE, an interesting bit of trivia kept popping up: Leonard Nimoy and William Shatner’s first appearance together was in UNCLE’s season one episode “The Project Strigas Affair.”You don’t really need a lot of context for the clip, but here’s a synopsis anyway: UNCLE is working to discredit a Balkan diplomat by selling him on a...

Damon Lindelof Admits Keeping Khan's Identity a Secret In Into Darkness Was a Bad Idea Damon Lindelof Admits Keeping Khan's Identity a Secret In Into Darkness Was a Bad Idea

Star Trek Into Darkness had plenty of unfortunate flaws, but if there’s one thing that it’s still mocked for, it’s how the production team approached keeping the identity of Benedict Cumberbatch’s villain away from moviegoers. Two years after the film came out, they’re finally starting to admit that was a mistake.Speaking to Variety about his current show, the HBO...

Language