LOADING ...

New Book Reveals Edward R. Murrow's Years As a Government Propagandist

Matt Novak May 25, 2016. 2 comments

“I don’t mind being called a propagandist,” Edward R. Murrow told a reporter at the Miami Herald in April of 1962. “So long as that propaganda is based on the truth.”

Today, Edward R. Murrow’s name is synonymous with integrity in journalism. He reported from the frontlines during World War II and took on Joe McCarthy’s communist witchhunt in the 1950s. But what’s less well known to Americans today is his role as the country’s leading propagandist in the early 1960s. A new book by Gregory M. Tomlin called Murrow’s Cold War: Public Diplomacy for the Kennedy Administration seeks to remedy that.

The term “propaganda” certainly carries with it a lot of negative connotations to Americans in the 21st century. But the word was used proudly during Murrow’s tenure as the head of the United States Information Agency (USIA) from 1961-1964 to describe government efforts to influence public opinion overseas. The Cold War was in constant danger of becoming hot. And USIA used countless film, TV, radio, and book programs to get out its message that America’s model of democracy and capitalism was superior to the Communist model of socialism and oppression.

The existence of Murrow’s last job (he’d die of lung cancer in 1965) is relatively well known to historians. But his unvarnished legacy as a propagandist remains fuzzy in the public imagination. Films like George Clooney’s Good Night and Good Luck (2005) and the countless journalism awards named for Murrow have helped gloss over his years as an official government mouthpiece. It should be noted that he was as good at his new job of active persuasion as he was at his old one in hard news. And perhaps better.

The United States Information Agency (known overseas as the United States Information Service) was founded in 1953 to conduct propaganda and psychological warfare operations around the world. The USIA wasn’t allowed to produce material for American consumption due to laws against propaganda aimed at Americans. And as such, the agency’s Cold War activities can be a huge blindspot for people in the United States. The USIA office that Murrow would help to define had an important impact on the way that people outside of the US viewed Americans.

Tomlin’s book takes us through Murrow’s earliest years at CBS in the mid-1930s, where he lied about his credentials to secure a job. Murrow made himself five years older on his CV and claimed to have degrees that he didn’t have, including a master’s degree from Stanford University. The irony of the fact that he was lying to get a job where he’d become the living symbol of integrity is lost on no one.

Tomlin then fast-forwards to Murrow’s years as director of the USIA under President Kennedy. We learn about Murrow’s dissatisfaction with the demands of rapidly commercializing TV industry in the late 1950s, and his pivot to public service when he was asked to head the USIA by the Kennedy administration. Interestingly, the USIA was seen as an agency full of left-leaning pinkos, despite its role as the consummate Cold Warrior. Congresspeople who were inclined to see Murrow as just another pinko constantly slashed funding for the agency despite its explicit role as a propaganda arm of the United States.

Tomlin’s new book explores the various fronts of Murrow’s propaganda battle in every medium, from the promotion of TV content on private stations around the world, to the USIA’s very own global radio network, Voice of America (VOA). But one of the most startling revelations goes above and beyond what we think of as typical propaganda or public diplomacy. Murrow offered counsel to the CIA about ways that he thought they should plan to incite insurrection in Cuba (more commonly known as Operation Northwoods ) as well as how they would publicize opposition to the Castro regime as if they had nothing to do with it.

In a December 10, 1962 memo from Murrow to the Director of Central Intelligence, the newsman-turned-propagandist was blunt about advocating for sabotage in Cuba. Murrow suggested that US radio programs feature Cuban dissidents encouraging relatively safe ways to gum up the works in the communist government.

“The Cuban audience should be urged to act with care and cautioned against open rebellion,” Murrow wrote. “The program would be based upon work slowdowns, purposeful inefficiency, purposeful waste, and relatively safe forms of sabotage. Specific examples of the activities urged would be putting glass and nails on the highways, leaving water running in public buildings, putting sand in machinery, wasting electricity, taking sick leave from work, damaging sugar stalks during the harvest, etc.”

Murrow explicitly said that these actions should not be attributed to the United States or the USIA. And that’s where modern day readers would probably be shocked to learn that the man from ye olde TV days was working so intimately with the CIA.

“The program would be strictly attributable to the Cuban exiles with no open participation by USIA or other government agencies,” Murrow continued in the memo to the Director of Central Intelligence. “If real results were achieved, the Voice of America [radio network] could report these as evidence of opposition to the Castro regime through interviews with refugees and extracts from letters.”

These and so many other anecdotes about Murrow’s use of media to tell America’s story abroad (often in more benign ways, like the production of documentaries about the Civil Rights movement) makes this book a worthwhile introduction into both the history of the USIA and the latter stages of Murrow’s career.

The one area where the book seems to falter is in speaking plainly about Murrow’s job. Murrow called his work propaganda, and the US government called his work propaganda. But for some reason, this word has been deemed too harsh for consumption here in the year 2016. Tomlin tells readers early on that because of the word’s negative connotations, he’ll be replacing the word with “public diplomacy” throughout the book. This decision gives the text an air of self-censorship.

As just one example from page 81, emphasis mine:

The U.S. government could saturate a foreign country with multiple forms of public diplomacy, but when disseminated by itself, information could not serve as the “magic bullet” to resolve national security challenges.

Saturated with public diplomacy? Such a phrase almost feels like it was created by a computer running find-and-replace. “Saturated with propaganda” not only feels more natural, but it certainly feels more honest.

Overall Tomlin’s book is a solid examination with plenty of interesting stories that I haven’t elaborated on here. As Tomlin notes, in the year 1963 alone, roughly 600 million people around the world watched a USIA-produced documentary every month. This is to say nothing of the thousands of hours of radio broadcasts distributed in almost forty languages.

Americans have very little understanding of the propaganda efforts done in its name during the Cold War through the USIA in close cooperation with the CIA and US military. Not to mention the propaganda efforts still currently being executed since the USIA was dissolved in 1999 and most of its efforts, including Voice of America, were taken up by the State Department.

The full story of the United States Information Agency, with one of America’s most famous newsman at its helm, is worthy of probably ten books. But for now readers will have to settle for just one, Murrow’s Cold War: Public Diplomacy for the Kennedy Administration .

2 Comments

Other Matt Novak's posts

Former Drug Company Execs, Pharmacists Arrested for Allegedly Flooding Small Towns With Opioids Former Drug Company Execs, Pharmacists Arrested for Allegedly Flooding Small Towns With Opioids

Federal officials have indicted two former executives at the pharmaceutical wholesaler Miami-Luken for allegedly distributing millions of opioid pills illegally in rural Appalachia. Two pharmacists have also been charged, according to a statement from the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Ohio.Miami-Luken supplied opiate painkillers like oxycodone and hydrocodone to over 200 pharmacies in Ohio, West Virginia,...

Iran Denies Claim That U.S. Military Destroyed Drone in the Strait of Hormuz Iran Denies Claim That U.S. Military Destroyed Drone in the Strait of Hormuz

The government of Iran has denied reports that the U.S. shot down an Iranian drone this week in the Strait of Hormuz, contradicting claims by the U.S. military and President Donald Trump that an enemy drone had been destroyed.“We have not lost any drone in the Strait of Hormuz nor anywhere else,” Iran’s Deputy Foreign Minister, Seyed Abbas Araqchi,...

Slack Resetting Thousands of User Passwords After Learning 2015 Breach Was Worse Than Previously Known Slack Resetting Thousands of User Passwords After Learning 2015 Breach Was Worse Than Previously Known

Slack is resetting roughly 100,000 user passwords for accounts that were active in 2015. The company has only recently learned that an old security breach from four years ago was perhaps worse than previously thought.The news, first reported by ZD Net and confirmed by Slack in an announcement on its website, will only affect about 1 percent of Slack’s...

Top Searches on Merriam-Webster Include 'Fascism' and 'Racism' After President Trump's Latest Rally Top Searches on Merriam-Webster Include 'Fascism' and 'Racism' After President Trump's Latest Rally

Donald Trump held another neo-fascist rally yesterday in North Carolina, where the crowd chanted things like “treason,” “traitor,” and “send her back,” while the president talked about Democratic members of Congress, including Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota. Online dictionary searches in the U.S. from last night show just how bad things have gotten.Merriam-Webster reports that the most common searches...

Suggested posts

U.S. Charges Seven Russians With Hacks Linked to Olympic Doping Scandal U.S. Charges Seven Russians With Hacks Linked to Olympic Doping Scandal

U.S. prosecutors on Thursday announced charges against seven Russian intelligence officers accused of cyberattacks against agencies investigating Russian doping and the poisoning of a former British spy.The Russian officials carried out “persistent and sophisticated computer intrusions” worldwide, with the aim of propagating disinformation around campaigns designed to shed a light on the Russian state-sponsored athlete doping program, according to...

Facebook Says It Removed 1.5 Million Videos of Christchurch Massacre Within 24 Hours Facebook Says It Removed 1.5 Million Videos of Christchurch Massacre Within 24 Hours

Facebook said on Saturday night that within 24 hours of a horrific attack on Muslims in Christchurch, New Zealand that killed at least 50 people and wounded dozens of others on March 15, it had blocked 1.5 million attempts to share a video of the attack live-streamed on Facebook by the shooter. Over 1.2 million of those attempts were...

China's 'Little Red Book'-Like App Is Blowing Up the Charts China's 'Little Red Book'-Like App Is Blowing Up the Charts

The most downloaded app in Apple Store’s China region, with over 100 million users, awards points for reading articles, taking quizzes, learning about socialist theory and watching videos about President Xi Jinping and the Communist Party. The app, Study the Great Nation, was developed by the public opinion research division of China’s Central Propaganda Department and tech company Alibaba,...

Facebook's Efforts 'Not Nearly Sufficient' in Genocide-Torn Myanmar, UN Investigator Says Facebook's Efforts 'Not Nearly Sufficient' in Genocide-Torn Myanmar, UN Investigator Says

It’s been nearly two years since the bloody peak of a social media-fueled genocide in Southeast Asia, but Facebook is still not doing enough to prevent the ongoing promotion of violence and hate in Myanmar on its social network, according to a member of the United Nations team that found the Silicon Valley company for years failed to stop...

Facebook Suspends Three Pages With Millions of Video Views, Saying They Need to Disclose Russia Ties Facebook Suspends Three Pages With Millions of Video Views, Saying They Need to Disclose Russia Ties

Facebook has suspended three video-centric pages run by Maffick Media, a company mostly owned by Ruptly, a subsidiary of the state-run RT (formerly Russia Today) network, CNN reported on Friday.According to CNN’s report, Facebook said it would reach out to the owners of the pages, who it said did not properly disclose where the pages were managed from or...

Declassified U2 Spy Plane Photos Expose Hidden Archaeological Sites Declassified U2 Spy Plane Photos Expose Hidden Archaeological Sites

During the Cold War, the United States flew U2 spy planes over Europe, the Middle East, and central eastern Asia in search of potential military targets. These missions inadvertently gathered historical information, which archaeologists are now using for scientific purposes.New research published last month in the science journal Advances in Archaeological Practice describes the first archaeological use of declassified...

Studio Exec in the 1920s: Movies Are 'Silent Propaganda' About America Studio Exec in the 1920s: Movies Are 'Silent Propaganda' About America

Movies are just movies, right? They can be frivolous entertainment, for sure. But they’re also serious business—both in terms of money and the way that they influence how we see the world. People fighting the Cold War knew this. That’s why we remember Senator Joe McCarthy and the infamous Hollywood blacklist. And that’s why VHS tapes of American action...

Cold War Spy Satellite Reveals Just How Fast the Himalayas Are Losing Ice Cold War Spy Satellite Reveals Just How Fast the Himalayas Are Losing Ice

During the Cold War, spy satellites were constantly circling the Earth. But while the intent of those satellites is generally to track human activities, the imagery they captured has also proved to be a trove of scientific data.The latest use of Cold War imagery has revealed a huge acceleration in Himalayan ice loss. The results published in Science Advances...

Meet the Deepfake Zuck, Same as the Flesh Zuck Meet the Deepfake Zuck, Same as the Flesh Zuck

Mark Zuckerberg may be famed for looking and acting like a (slightly damp ) synthetic being trying to infiltrate human society , but a team of artists working with advertising company Canny appears to built a software version of the Facebook CEO that could one day threaten to make hardware Zuckerberg obsolete.The artists in question, Bill Posters and Daniel...

The U.S. Army Once Kept $1 Billion Worth of LSD in a Maryland Office for Some Reason The U.S. Army Once Kept $1 Billion Worth of LSD in a Maryland Office for Some Reason

James Ketchum, an Army psychiatrist who conducted controversial drug experiments on members of the U.S. military, died last month, on May 27, at the age of 87. And while Ketchum’s legacy is filled with plenty of weird and horrifying tales, there’s one story that should get more attention in the wake of his death.Specifically, we should probably talk about...

Language